Showing posts sorted by date for query baptism. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query baptism. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Monday, August 03, 2026

The Orthodox Study Bible: Creed

The Orthodox Study Bible: Creed 

Preface 

THE ORTHODOX STUDY BIBLE, NEW TESTAMENT AND PSALMS (1993) Saint Athanasius Orthodox Academy, Nashville, Tennessee, Thomas Nelson Publishers


I decided to edit and combine the previous parts 1-2 that made two articles, into one article.

The review of this fine, academic, source continues.

Glossary from Reverend John Morris, PhD

Quote

'A statement of belief. Creeds in their earlier form were used by the apostles, and many are recorded in the New Testament (Eph. 5: 14; 1 Tim. 3: 16; 2 Tim. 2:11-13). The creed used throughout the Church was adopted at the Council of Nicea in A.D. 325 and expanded at the Council of Constantinople in A.D. 381. The Nicene Creed is used at baptisms, the Divine Liturgy, and in personal prayers.' (796).

Comments

From my Reformed, Anabaptist (evangelical) theological background, the Divine Liturgy is not terminology used. This is within Orthodoxy, language for the 'Eucharistic service of the Orthodox Church'. (802).

Orthodox Church in America: The Divine Liturgy 

Cited 

'The word liturgy means common work or common action. The Divine Liturgy is the common work of the Orthodox Church. It is the official action of the Church formally gathered together as the chosen People of God. The word church, as we remember, means a gathering or assembly of people specifically chosen and called apart to perform a particular task.'

Cited

'The Divine Liturgy is the common action of Orthodox Christians officially gathered to constitute the Orthodox Church. It is the action of the Church assembled by God in order to be together in one community to worship, to pray, to sing, to hear God’s Word, to be instructed in God’s commandments, to offer itself with thanksgiving in Christ to God the Father, and to have the living experience of God’s eternal kingdom through communion with the same Christ Who is present in his people by the Holy Spirit.'

Cited 

'The Divine Liturgy is always done by Orthodox Christians on the Lord’s Day which is Sunday, the “day after Sabbath” which is symbolic of the first day of creation and the last day—or as it is called in Holy Tradition, the eighth day—of the Kingdom of God. This is the day of Christ’s resurrection from the dead, the day of God’s judgment and victory predicted by the prophets, the Day of the Lord which inaugurates the presence and the power of the “kingdom to come” already now within the life of this present world.' 

'The Divine Liturgy is also celebrated by the Church on special feast days.' 

Saint George Greek Orthodox Cathedral: The Divine Liturgy

Greenville, South Carolina

Cited 

'What is the Purpose of the Divine Liturgy? The transformation of wine, water and bread into the Divine Body and Blood of Christ; for the sanctification of the faithful, who receive remission of their sins and the inheritance of the kingdom of heaven.' St.Cabasilas 

Cited

'It is the coming together of the heavenly Kingdom with earthly life. The Church of heaven, the Church triumphant, and the church here on earth, the Church Militant, join in this grand celebration to glorify God and to be in union with Him. 

We come to this service to be transformed through the partaking of Holy Communion. This is the same as saying we partake of Jesus Christ's Flesh and Divinity. Holy Communion and the Divine Liturgy cannot be separated. This the greatest of all mysteries. All should come prepared to be partakers of the Divine gift.'

Cited

'What is the Meaning of the Word Liturgy? The word Liturgy comes from an ancient Greek word leitos (people) and erogon (work), Literally it means the work of the people. This word was used initially to refer to service given to the state by citizens for the betterment of the public good. We can think of the divine Liturgy as the public work for the benefit of the people so God’s people will be cared for by Him. As we participate in this service we are serving God through our work in the Divine Liturgy.'

Wikipedia: Liturgy 

λειτουργία/leitourgia 


'Liturgy (leitourgia) is a Greek composite word meaning originally a public duty, a service to the state undertaken by a citizen. Its elements are leitos (from leos = laos, people) meaning public, and ergo (obsolete in the present stem, used in future erxo, etc.), to do. From this we have leitourgos, "a man who performs a public duty", "a public servant", often used as equivalent to the Roman lictor; then leitourgeo, "to do such a duty", leitourgema, its performance, and leitourgia, the public duty itself.'

New Advent sources below. not cited by me personally

Cited

CABROL AND LECLERCQ, Monumenta Ecclesiæ Liturgica. I, Reliquiæ Liturgicæ Vetustissimæ (Paris, 1900-2); 

BRIGHTMAN, Liturgies Eastern and Western, I. Eastern Liturgies (Oxford, 1896); 

DANIEL, Codex Liturgicus Ecclesiæ universæ (4 vols., Leipzig, 1847-53); 

RAUSCHEN, Florilegium Patristicum, VII. Monumenta eucharistica et liturgica vetustissima (Bonn, 1909); FUNK, Patres Apostolici (2 vols., Tübingen, 1901), and Didascalia et Constitutiones Apostolorum (Paderborn, 1905), the quotations in this article are made from these editions; 

PROBST, Liturgie der drei ersten christl. Jahrh. (Tübingen, 1870); 

IDEM, Liturgie des vierten Jahr. u. deren Reform (Münster, 1893); 

DREWS, Untersuchungen über die sogenannte clementin. Liturgie (Tübingen, 1906); 

DUCHESNE, Origines du Cuite chrét. (Paris, 1898); 

RAUSCHEN, Eucharistie und Buss-sakrament in den ersten sechs Jahrh. der Kirche (Freiburg, 1908); 

CABROL, Les Origines liturgiques (Paris, 1906); 

IDEM, Introduction aux Etudes liturgiques (Paris, 1907). For further bibliography see articles on each liturgy. For liturgical languages, as well as liturgical science, treating of the regulation, history, and dogmatic value of the Liturgy, see RITES.


Smartfaith.net

Cited 

'Kevin Simington (B.Th. Dip. Min.) is a theologian, apologist and social commentator.' 

Cited 

'Contrary to some people’s misguided views, liturgy was not a later ‘add-on’ instituted by a stultified church but was a vital part of Christian worship from the very beginning. The New Testament contains many references to the ongoing practice of liturgical worship as well as actual examples of first century liturgy.'

Comments

The smartfaith.net comments are in agreement with the Orthodox Study Bible, in as much that liturgy was practiced within the New Testament and the New Testament era. To use the first New Testament reference from the Orthodox text, quoting a saying in Ephesians 5: 14:

New American Standard Bible (NASB)

14 For this reason [a]it says, “Awake, sleeper, And arise from the dead, And Christ will shine on you.” 

Footnotes a) Ephesians 5:14 Or He

The Orthodoxy text uses the 

New King James Version (NKJV)

14 Therefore He says: “Awake, you who sleep, Arise from the dead, And Christ will give you light.”

The Orthodoxy text states that verse 14 is an early baptism hymn, and that baptism is illumination. (450).

From my Reformed and Anabaptist perspective, baptism is a key New Testament practice (ordinance or sacrament, depending on the denomination) that represents a sign of regeneration (John 3, Titus 3, 1 Peter 1: 23) for a believer. 

1 Peter 3: 21

New American Standard Bible (NASB)

Corresponding to that, baptism now saves you—not the removal of dirt from the flesh, but an appeal to God for a good conscience—through the resurrection of Jesus Christ...
---

A good conscience exists via regeneration and the applied atoning and resurrection work of Jesus Christ to a believer.

From this brief review in Part 1, we can see that a creed is a statement of belief; whereas liturgy is a form of public worship. So, a liturgy may be a creed and vice-versa.

Both are a biblical means of expressing theological truths. 

Selected source from cited links 

Fortescue, A. (1910). Liturgy, In The Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company. Retrieved March 20, 2022 from New Advent: http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09306a.htm

The Nicene Creed

C.A. Blaising explains that the Council of Nicea was the first ecumenical (many churches, my add) council in the history of the Christian Church. (774). This was convened by Roman Emperor, Constantine. (774). The Nicene Creed which resulted was the first to have the claim of universal theological authority throughout the Roman Empire (774). From Blaising, it was an 'almost unanimous production' (774) that was accepted for the universal Church.

The Nicene Creed is from the Council of Nicea in 325 AD/CE. Paraphrasing the Pocket Dictionary, the Council of Nicea was convened by the Roman Empire, Constantine (83) in regards to Arianism (83), which denied the deity of Jesus Christ, based on the teachings of Arius (died 335-336) (15). 

George Newlands explains that Arius believed that Jesus Christ was the incarnate Logos, but was subject to change. (103). The Logos, itself, was therefore subject to change. (103). The Logos for Arius would not be eternal God. This is error in my view as the nature of God the Son, God the Word (Logos/Λόγος), is eternal, infinite and immutable (the Gospel of John, Chapter 1, clearly portrays the Word of God, as fully God). As Jesus Christ was fully human, his body would change, as would any other human being. But his divine nature, as the God the Word, Logos, would not. 

Does the resurrected body of Jesus Christ change? As now immortal, I doubt it. (Referencing the example of resurrected humanity in 1 Corinthians 15).

Arius reasoned that as God was immutable, my term paraphrasing (103), Jesus Christ could not be God. (103). Therefore he reasoned the Logos was not God. This is a misunderstanding of trinitarian theology and the biblical text by Arius and within Arianism. The same could be stated for denying the deity of Christ over the issue of impassibility (103). Jesus Christ as fully human, would suffer, but God in nature cannot suffer. God is impassible in my view, at least in that God's ontological nature cannot be changed by suffering. I do reason that God with infinite knowledge, does understand all suffering.


Blaising documents that Arianism argued that the Son cannot have the same exact essence as God the Father, because then 'the essence would be divisible'. (774). Arianism stated that the Son only does God the Father's will, as do all other creatures. (774). 

The Pocket Dictionary documents that the Nicene Creed teaches that God the Son is of one substance with God the Father (83) as in homoousios (83), ὁμοούσιος (my add). As spirit (John 4: 24) God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit, have one nature as three distinctions/persons. The Nicene Creed was revamped slightly at the Council of Constantinople in 381 AD/CE (83). 

V.L.Walter reasons that 'the most compelling argument against Arianism' (75), in agreement with Athanasius, is that only God incarnate, could reconcile and redeem fallen humanity to a holy God. (75).

I would state that God the Son, Jesus Christ, as infinite could outlast finite sin on the cross. A finite being, as in Arianism, could not do so. God the Son, Jesus Christ, as perfect human being, could serve as the divine sacrifice for sin and simultaneously conquer death.

Romans 6: 23 King James Version (KJV)

23 For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.

The Nicene Creed, in my view, biblically protects the New Testament, trinitarian theology of the deity of Jesus Christ. Yes, in the incarnation, God the Son, God the Word (John 1) took an additional human nature that does not mix with the infinite, eternal nature of God. God the Son, remains, fully God the Son, even as incarnate Jesus Christ.
---

Arius


Cited

'As with most heretics, Arius is known primarily through the eyes of his opponents; only a few letters of Arius himself survive. Modern studies of Arius and Arianism are scarce: Henry Melvill Gwatkin, Studies of Arianism: Chiefly Referring to the Character and Chronology of the Reaction Which Followed the Council of Nicaea (1882; 2d ed. 1900), and John Henry Newman, The Arians of the Fourth Century (1833; 4th rev. ed. 1876), are helpful but prejudiced and outdated. Of general surveys, G.L. Prestige, Fathers and Heretics (1940); Jean Daniélou and Henri Marrou, The Christian Centuries, vol. 1: The First Six Hundred Years (1963; trans. 1964); and Henry Chadwick, The Early Church (trans. 1967), can be consulted with profit.'

ATHANASIUS, SAINT, PATRIARCH OF ALEXANDRIA, (-373) (1970). St. Athanasius on the Incarnation : the Treatise De Incarnatione. Verbi Dei. London :A. R. Mowbray & Co.

BLAISING, C.A (1996) ‘Nicea Council of’ in Walter A. Elwell (ed.) Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Books.

CAIRNS, EARLE E. (1981) Christianity Through The Centuries, Grand Rapids, Zondervan Publishing House. 

GRENZ, STANLEY J., DAVID GURETZKI and CHERITH FEE NORDLING (1999) Pocket Dictionary of Theological Terms, Downers Grove, Ill., InterVarsity Press. 

NEWLANDS, GEORGE (1999) 'Christology', in Alan Richardson and John Bowden (eds.), A New Dictionary of Christian Theology, Kent, SCM Press Limited.

SHELBY, BRUCE L. (1982) Church History In Plain Language, Word Books, Waco, Texas. 

WALTER, V.L. (1996) ‘Arianism’ in Walter A. Elwell (ed.) Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Books.

Saturday, May 10, 2025

The Orthodox Study Bible: Acts 2: 21 & Romans 10: 13 Revised & Non-exhaustive

The Orthodox Study Bible: Acts 2: 21 & Romans 10: 13 Revised & Non-exhaustive

Preface

Revised version of two articles (2021) for one version on Blogger.

The Orthodox Study Bible, New Testament and Psalms, (1993) Saint Athanasius Orthodox Academy, Thomas Nelson Publishers, Nashville, Tennessee. 

This Orthodoxy Bible uses the New King James Bible (NKJV) 

Acts 2: 21

21 And it shall come to pass That whoever calls on the name of the Lord Shall be saved.’

In context, the Apostle Peter quotes from the Old Testament/Hebrew Bible, Book of Joel 2: 28-32.

With these New Testament citations of the Old Testament, as Peter is cited in Acts 2: 16-21, the context provided is not identical as the older original. A reason is that the Hebrew Bible and its covenant, although remaining as scripture, are accompanied by, as in progressive revelation, the New Testament and its covenant (Luke 22: 20 & Hebrews as examples). The New Testament emphasis is the new covenant, doctrines and theology, which replaces the old covenant. Still the Hebrew Bible should be understood as well in its original context within the old covenant. 

Joel Briefly

In his Joel commentary, author Paul E. Leonard explains that Joel, the son of Pethuel, is basically unknown other than being the author of this text within the Hebrew Bible. (884). The name 'Joel' means 'Yahweh is God' (884), and Leonard writes that it is unclear whether this was a given name at birth, or a ministry name given later in life. (884). This Hebrew Bible writer presented a clear message and then basically disappeared from history. (884). The Book of Joel's message is that as a plague of locusts strikes (884), it will be 'destroying all plant life in its path' (884). I view this as a termination of the useable plant life, not a complete destruction of the ecological system. Leonard states that based on the text, there will be no harvest, and the cattle and sheep will die because of lack of food. (884). He notes Joel 1: 18. (884).

Joel 1:18 New King James Version (NKJV)

18 How the animals groan! The herds of cattle are restless, Because they have no pasture; Even the flocks of sheep [a]suffer punishment. 

Footnote

a) Joel 1:18 LXX, Vg. are made desolate

Joel is warning his readers that these sufferings are a 'prelude to the coming apocalyptic judgment of God' (884). Joel 2: 1-3 from the same version is referenced:

Blow the [a]trumpet in Zion, And sound an alarm in My holy mountain! Let all the inhabitants of the land tremble; For the day of the Lord is coming, For it is at hand: 2 A day of darkness and gloominess, A day of clouds and thick darkness, Like the morning clouds spread over the mountains. A people come, great and strong, The like of whom has never been; Nor will there ever be any such after them, Even for many successive generations. 3 A fire devours before them, And behind them a flame burns; The land is like the Garden of Eden before them, And behind them a desolate wilderness; Surely nothing shall escape them 

Footnote

a) Joel 2:1 ram’s horn 

Joel 2:28-32 New King James Version (NKJV)

28 “And it shall come to pass afterward That I will pour out My Spirit on all flesh; Your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, Your old men shall dream dreams, Your young men shall see visions. 29 And also on My menservants and on My maidservants I will pour out My Spirit in those days. 30 “And I will show wonders in the heavens and in the earth: Blood and fire and pillars of smoke. 31 The sun shall be turned into darkness, And the moon into blood, Before the coming of the great and awesome day of the Lord. 32 And it shall come to pass That whoever calls on the name of the Lord Shall be [a]saved. For in Mount Zion and in Jerusalem there shall be [b]deliverance, As the Lord has said, Among the remnant whom the Lord calls. 

Footnotes 

a) Joel 2:32 Or delivered 
b) Joel 2:32 Or salvation

Leonard acknowledges that in regards to salvation, both Jew and Gentile are mentioned in the New Testament and so New Testament salvation was wider than in the context of Joel. (889). 'However it is not clear that Joel understood it this way.' (889).

Acts 2: 21 continued

I am more focused however in this limited space, website format, on the Acts version. This article will be unexhaustive.

The new covenant...


Sourced

Luke 22:20 

New American Standard Bible (NASB) 

20 And in the same way He took the cup after they had eaten, saying, “This cup which is (a) poured out for you is the (b) new covenant in My blood. 

a Mt 26:28 Mk 14:24
b Ex 24:8 Je 31:31 1 Co 11:25 2 Co 3:6 Heb 8:8 Heb 8:13 Heb 9:15

Cited 

PROBLEM: In Acts 2, Pentecost arrives, and the disciples are filled with the Holy Spirit. In response to criticism, Peter says that what they hear and see was “spoken by the prophet Joel” (cf. Joel 2:28–32). Yet, in the passage that Peter quotes, there are events in it that did not happen at Pentecost, like the moon turning to blood. Does Peter err on this occasion? 

SOLUTION: First, Peter was simply showing that Pentecost involved a partial or initial fulfillment of Joel 2:28–32. This partial fulfillment was in regard to the indwelling Holy Spirit for believers. And this is exactly what happened on the day of Pentecost. Joel says that God “will pour out My spirit on all flesh ... I will pour out My Spirit in those days” (Joel 2:28–29). And God did pour forth His Spirit on the day of Pentecost. 

Second, Peter’s reference was to indicate that the last days had been inaugurated (cf. Heb. 1:1–2; 2:4). The wonders of the sky above and the signs on the earth beneath (Acts 19–21) are to take place later on in earth’s history at the time of Christ’s second coming. Notice that these things will happen “before the ... great and notable day of the Lord” (v. 20) which is yet future (cf. Matt. 24:1ff). 

This excerpt is from When Critics Ask: A Popular Handbook on Bible Difficulties (Wheaton, Ill.: Victor Books, 1992). © 2014 Norman Geisler and Thomas Howe. 

The Orthodoxy text states in regards to Acts 2: 16-21, that Joel was one of the early prophets (ninth century, BCE) that proclaimed God's sovereign Lordship and judgement in the last days. (275). With Pentecost the first part of the prophecy was answered with the outpouring of God the Holy Spirit to believers. The second part will be fulfilled at the second coming of Jesus Christ. (275). 


Some key New Testament sections related to the second coming are Matthew 24, 1 Thessalonians 4-5, 2 Thessalonians 2:7-12. (My add)

Cited

Bibliography R. Anderson, The Coming Prince (1915); W. E. Blackstone, Jesus Is Coming (1917); L. S. Chafer, Systematic Theology, IV, 305-307 (1947); L. Berkhof, The Second Coming of Christ (1953); R. Pache, The Return of Jesus Christ (1955); J. F. Walvoord, The Millennial Kingdom (1959), 263-275; J. D. Pentecost, Things To Come (1961), 370-426.


Cited 

Key for the Acts-Joel example: 

Different Languages: The Hebrew Bible was written in Hebrew, with parts in Aramaic, the New Testament in Greek, with parts in Aramaic. 

Indirect quotations: The New Testament writers frequently quote the Old Testament without verbal exactness. Most likely, many of the quotations were from memory. At times the citations were made according to the sense of the Old Testament rather than making a direct quote. Sometimes the quotations in Scripture are indirect not direct. An indirect quotation does not cite someone directly but does report accurately what that person said. 

Indirect quotes were used to emphasize the New Testament covenant, doctrines and theology.






Strong's Concordance 

Original Word: ἐπικαλέω 
GRK: ὃς ἂν ἐπικαλέσηται τὸ ὄνομα 
Verb-Aorist-Subjunctive-Middle-3rd Person Singular

NT Greek.org 

Corey Keating 

Cited 

As far as the tense of the verb in the subjunctive mood, it should be remembered that the subjunctive only shows the kind of action (verbal aspect or ‘aktionsart’) and not time. Only verbs in the indicative mood indicate time in an absolute sense. (See intermediate discussion of verb tenses). However, the ‘time’ implied by the subjunctive is usually future since it is a mood of contingency. Thus the future indicative and the aorist subjunctive are closely related and sometimes used in substitution for each other. 

Aorist is past tense. Subjunctive is usually, future tense. The middle is neither active or passive.

Humanly speaking, based on the New Testament Greek, and accurate translations, the Lord can be theologically called upon, in biblical times up to present times and future times, within this present realm.

STRONG, J. (1890)(1986) Strong's Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible, Burlington, Welch Publishing Company.
---

John Calvin: Acts 2:21

'And it shall come to pass That whoever calls on the name of the Lord' (36)

Calvin reasons 'God invites everyone to himself for salvation, without exception.' (36). One key example mentioned by Calvin is Romans 10: 13. (36). 'Only our disbelief stops us from calling on God.' He quotes Jesus Christ in John 16:24, as in Ask and you shall receive. (36).

Edited from 2010 Theodicy and Practical Theology: PhD thesis, the University of Wales, Trinity Saint David, Lampeter


John Calvin’s (1543)(1998) theology holds to a strong view on God’s sovereignty and to a limited view of human freedom. In modern, but not Reformation era terms, Calvin could be considered a compatibilist and explains that those who committed wrong actions performed them willfully and deliberately. Calvin viewed God as working his good purposes through the evil conduct of people, but he pointed out that God’s motives in willing these deeds were pure while those who committed wrong had wicked motives. Calvin (1543)(1998: 37). 

Calvin reasons that a person is not forced or coerced to believe in the gospel. Calvin (1543)(1996: 68).
He suggests outward human preaching ‘strikes only the ears’ while the inward instruction of the Holy Spirit is how a person is enlightened in Christ. Human preaching is valuable in that it works at times in conjunction with the Holy Spirit transforming individuals. Calvin (1543)(1996: 233). There is a traditional Christian and Reformed concept and theology that the Holy Spirit is God and does the work that only God can do. The Holy Spirit works directly upon a human mind, in a sense remaking a person and creating a person after the image of Christ. 

The Orthodox Study Bible, New Testament and Psalms, (1993) Saint Athanasius Orthodox Academy, Thomas Nelson Publishers, Nashville, Tennessee. 

Romans 10: 13

Romans 10:13 New King James Version 13 For “whoever calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved.” (NKJV).

In regards to Romans 10: 13, the Orthodox Bible explains 'All may come freely if they will.' (363).  

This is coming from an Orthodox, not Reformed, theological perspective that generally, in my opinion, in philosophical terms, is more incompatiblistic than compatibilistic. In other words, a greater emphasis on human free will and somewhat less emphasis on the sovereignty of God.

John Calvin: Romans 10: 13-17

On Roman 10: 14-17, to follow up on verse 13.

Cited

And this is a remarkable passage with regard to the efficacy of preaching; for he testifies, that by it faith is produced. He had indeed before declared, that of itself it is of no avail; but that when it pleases the Lord to work, it becomes the instrument of his power. And indeed the voice of man can by no means penetrate into the soul; and mortal man would be too much exalted, were he said to have the power to regenerate us; the light also of faith is something sublimer than what can be conveyed by man: but all these things are no hindrances, that God should not work effectually through the voice of man, so as to create faith in us through his ministry. 

It must be further noticed, that faith is grounded on nothing else but the truth of God; for Paul does not teach us that faith springs from any other kind of doctrine, but he expressly restricts it to the word of God; and this restriction would have been improper if faith could rest on the decrees of men. Away then with all the devices of men when we speak of the certainty of faith. (347).

Cranfield in his Romans commentary explains that Paul in Romans 10 reasoned that all who invoke the name of the Lord, 'that is Yahweh, will be saved.' (261). The term 'Lord' here for Paul, is applied to Christ. (261). I reason we have trinitarian theology here as the Lord Jesus is drawn to the Father through God the Holy Spirit. Mounce reminds us that someone must be preaching the good news in order for it to be accepted. (211). I am in agreement with this very New Testament concept as a compatibilist within the Reformed tradition, as I reason the Holy Spirit convinces through regeneration the chosen to embrace the gospel. This is not force or coercion. A person does not simply wake up a regenerate Christian one day, without having embraced the gospel through the Holy Spirit.

Theology

True New Testament regeneration (John 3, Titus 3, 1 Peter 1) is via God the Holy Spirit, by the lead of God the Father within the applied atoning and resurrection work of God the Son, to believers. Human beings within a fallen nature, embrace degrees of sin and evil. They are not forced or coerced to believe in the gospel, although admittedly, God may force or coerce events leading to human beings being regenerated in conversion, which is humanly embraced. Human beings within a fallen nature, embrace sin and evil. They are not forced or coerced, in unbelief, although admittedly God may force or coerce events leading to further hardened views toward God (Romans 9, Exodus 1-18).

It is this theological and philosophical (philosophy of religion) writer's view that human moral accountability exists where within the fallen (Genesis 1-3, Romans) nature, the human will, acts and actions are not forced or coerced. Every believer embraces the gospel even as God first and essentially, regenerates. Every unbeliever rejects the gospel, even as God chooses not to regenerate such a person. This is an aspect of my compatibilism/soft determinism within a Reformed tradition.

Titus 3: 5-7: Regeneration

Titus 3:5-7

New American Standard Bible (NASB)

5 He saved us, not on the basis of deeds which we have done in righteousness, but according to His mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewing by the Holy Spirit, 6 whom He poured out upon us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior, 7 so that being justified by His grace we would be made heirs [a]according to the hope of eternal life.

Bible Hub

Strong 3824

'Strong's Concordance paliggenesia: regeneration, renewal Original Word: παλιγγενεσία, ας, ἡ Part of Speech: Noun, Feminine Transliteration: paliggenesia Phonetic Spelling: (pal-ing-ghen-es-ee'-ah)

Short Definition: a new birth, regeneration Definition: a new birth, regeneration, renewal.'

From Titus 3: 5

The main text

Spiritual rebirth (figurative), spiritual regeneration (figurative). (72).

Being spiritually transformed by God, to be in relationship, fellowship with God through the applied atoning and resurrection work of Jesus Christ. Spiritually enlightened by the triune God in order to accept the salvific work of God. The Father sends, the Son completes the atoning and resurrection work and the Holy Spirit regenerates and yet the trinity is of one infinite, eternal essence and works together in unity.

Greek scholar Bauer documents this as:

The rebirth of the redeemed person. (606). The regeneration and rebirth via the Holy Spirit. (606).

Greek New Testament: 

With five Greek manuscript versions there is agreement on: paliggenesiaV

Pastor Courson explains that those in Christ have been 'washed and renewed' (1424), not because of our own human righteousness, but because of the work of Jesus Christ. (1424). We have been renewed  and washed. (1424). Washing is symbolic, in part at least through baptism, in my view. Although there is the idea of being cleansed of sin through the sanctification process.

Nute suggests in his commentary that washing is the cleansing in the new birth. (1496). And this may include the thought of baptism as a symbol of cleansing. (1496). The Pocket Dictionary defines regeneration as rebirth or re-creation as in being born again. (101). But salvation does include legal justification and the imputed righteousness of Jesus Christ to believers, and as well, sanctification.

Theology II

My final comments are that Acts 2: 21 and Romans 10: 13, and supporting contexts, not to simply prooftext, work with my Reformed theology that whom God regenerates, he/she freely believe in the gospel. This means that whoever calls upon the name of the Lord and everyone that calls upon the name of the Lord, has belief an in/on the true God and Lord in salvation (justification and sanctification), through grace through faith alone. It does not mean that all believers are particularly theologically or doctrinally astute. In other words, I certainly believe, for example, there are non-Reformed believers and that none of us have perfect belief, theology, doctrines and dogma.

Biblically and throughout Church history, there are false believers that call upon the name of the Lord, but are not regenerated in true belief. These are in my view persons trusting in work's righteousness theology that also have an ontologically wrong view of God.

See


BAUER, WALTER. (1979) A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, Translated by Eric H. Wahlstrom, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.

CALVIN, JOHN (1552)(1995) Acts, Translated by Watermark, Nottingham, Crossway Books.

CALVIN, JOHN (1539)(1509-1564), Tim Perrine, CCEL Staff Writer, Commentary on Romans, Translated, Grand Rapids, Christian Classics Ethereal Library, 

CALVIN, JOHN (1539)(1998) The Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book IV, Translated by Henry Beveridge, Grand Rapids, The Christian Classic Ethereal Library, Wheaton College. http://www.ccel.org/ccel/calvin/institutes.html 

CALVIN, JOHN (1540)(1973) Romans and Thessalonians, Translated by Ross Mackenzie, Grand Rapids, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. 

CALVIN, JOHN (1543)(1996) The Bondage and Liberation of the Will, Translated by G.I. Davies, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House.

COURSON, JON (2005) Application Commentary, Thomas Nelson, Nashville. 

GRENZ, STANLEY J., DAVID GURETZKI AND CHERITH FEE NORDLING (1999) Pocket Dictionary of Theological Terms, Downers Grove, Ill., InterVarsity Press. 

LEONARD, Paul E. (1986) in 'Joel', The International Bible Commentary, F.F. Bruce, General Editor, Grand Rapids, Zondervan/Marshall Pickering.

NUTE, ALAN G. (1986) in 'Titus', The International Bible Commentary, F.F. Bruce, General Editor, Grand Rapids, Zondervan/Marshall Pickering. 

STRONG, J. (1890)(1986) Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible, Pickering, Ontario, Welch Publishing Company.

Friday, November 29, 2024

Holiness v. Moral Uprightness (PhD Edit)

Holiness v. Moral Uprightness (PhD Edit)

1541152532phpowJZsx uwtsd aerial official

Preface

Photo: The University of Wales, Trinity Saint David, official

2010 Theodicy and Practical Theology: PhD thesis, the University of Wales, Trinity Saint David, Lampeter

Edited and updated section from PhD with additional website content. Originally published on Blogger 20200512. Updated 20241129.

Holiness v. Moral Uprightness (PhD Edit) 

Roman Catholic theologian Alan Schreck (1984) notes that because of God’s holy nature, sin is opposed to God’s purity. Schreck (1984: 195-196). Nothing impure or sinful can enter God’s presence. Schreck (1984: 195-196). Donald G. Bloesch (1987) explains that the knowledge of God leading to theological dogmatics should be for the sake of ethical service for God. Bloesch (1987: 12). Dogmatic theology should not exist for the sake of itself. Christians should live in service to their neighbours. Bloesch (1987: 12). He mentions that followers are to be holy by being separated by God from the world system, in a nearness to God. Bloesch (1987: 211). Bloesch deduces this is not the same as ‘moral uprightness’ Bloesch (1987: 211), but consists of followers living in Christ. Bloesch (1987: 211). He notes that in every human system of ethics there is demonstrated a human flaw that prohibits people from fulfilling a moral requirement. Bloesch (1987: 34). Bloesch is discussing ethical systems and not a defence or theodicy, but still the concepts of human nature and actions relate. Bloesch (1987: 34). In contrast, in the context of atonement and justice Bloesch (1987: 97), in God’s holiness, God forgives and forbears and demonstrates his love. Bloesch (1987: 97).  

Concerning the idea of God being holy, Stanley J. Grenz, David Guretzki and Cherith Fee Nordling (1999) write the term holy is a Biblical idea, generally meaning to be set apart. Grenz, Guretzki, and Nordling (1999: 60). It is described of God who is set apart from his creation, pure from any of the evil within it. Grenz, Guretzki, and Nordling (1999: 60). Mennonite Old Testament scholar Elmer A. Martens (1990) suggests holiness is concerned with the idea of separation, not separation from something, but separation to something. Martens (1990: 94). Biblically this type of holiness has to do with separation of a person to God. Martens (1990: 94).

Augustine writes that God is holy and the sovereign divine governor of the universe who is completely just in punishing evildoers, and God is not the cause of their wrong actions. Augustine (388-395)(1964: 3). God can rightly judge people because each evil person is the cause of his/her rebellion against God. Augustine (388-395)(1964: 3). 

Website additional content

Christ is the lamb slain from the foundations of the world (Revelation 13: 8). Also...

Ephesians 1:3-4 New American Standard Bible (NASB) 3 Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ, 4 just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we would be holy and blameless before [a]Him. In love Footnotes: (a) Ephesians 1:4 Or Him, in love
 

A Protestant, Reformed, evangelical, perspective, views justification as a legal term meaning the sinner is acquitted (69). This justification makes the now regenerated Christian acceptable to the Holy God. This is through justification by grace through faith (69). (Pocket: 69). This is imputed justification and righteousness of Jesus Christ to chosen sinners within the applied atonement. This does connect to holiness, in a sense, as indeed being justified in the righteousness of Christ separates the regenerate (John 3, Titus 3, 1 Peter 1) from the unregenerate, for holiness.


Titus 3: 5


Edited 

'by the washing of regeneration and renewing by the Holy Spirit' from the New American Standard Bible (NASB) 


Strong's 3824

Strong's Concordance paliggenesia: regeneration, renewal 

Original Word: παλιγγενεσία, ας, ἡ 

Part of Speech: Noun, Feminine 

Transliteration: paliggenesia 

Phonetic Spelling: (pal-ing-ghen-es-ee'-ah) 

Short Definition: a new birth, regeneration 

Definition: a new birth, regeneration, renewal.

From Titus 3: 5 The main text of Strong's presents: Spiritual rebirth (figurative), spiritual regeneration (figurative). (72). Greek scholar Bauer documents this as: The rebirth of the redeemed person. (606). The regeneration and rebirth via the Holy Spirit. (606).


With five Greek manuscript versions there is agreement on: paliggenesiaV

Jon Courson writes that those in Christ have been 'washed and renewed' (1424), not because of our own human righteousness, but because of the work of Jesus Christ. (1424). I suggest this supports a theology of justification, the applied righteousness of Christ to believers, and salvation for believers, through grace through faith, alone. We have been renewed and washed. (1424). Washing is symbolic, in part at least through baptism, in my view. Although there is the idea of being cleansed of sin through the sanctification process. 

Nute suggests in his commentary that washing is the cleansing in the new birth. (1496). And this may include the thought of baptism as a symbol of cleansing. (1496). The Pocket Dictionary defines regeneration as rebirth or re-creation as in being born again. (101). Salvation does include legal justification and the imputed righteousness of Jesus Christ to believers, and as well, sanctification.

John 3

Again from my PhD, Herman Bavinck (1918)(2006) equates the term regeneration with rebirth. Bavinck (1918)(2006: 46). In the Gospel of John 3, Jesus Christ does not literally speak of a person being born a second time, but literally insists that a person be reborn and spiritually transformed from above.


John 3: 3

γεννηθῇ be born

ἄνωθεν from above


Strong's 1080

Strong's Concordance gennaó: to beget, to bring forth 

Original Word: γεννάω 

Part of Speech: Verb Transliteration: gennaó 

Phonetic Spelling: (ghen-nah'-o) 

Definition: to beget, to bring forth Usage: I beget (of the male), (of the female) I bring forth, give birth to.


Strong's 509

Strong's Concordance anóthen: from above 

Original Word: ἄνωθεν 

Part of Speech: Adverb Transliteration: anóthen 

Phonetic Spelling: (an'-o-then) 

Definition: from above 

Usage: (a) from above, from heaven, (b) from the beginning, from their origin (source), from of old, (c) again, anew.

1 Peter 1: 3


ἀναγεννήσας having begotten again


Strong's 313

Strong's Concordance anagennaó: to beget again 

Original Word: ἀναγεννάω 

Part of Speech: Verb 

Transliteration: anagennaó 

Phonetic Spelling: (an-ag-en-nah'-o) 

Definition: to beget again 

Usage: I beget again, beget into a new life.

Bauer documents ἀναγεννάω (page 51), defined as beget again, be born again, figurative of spiritual rebirth of Christians. (51). This is the context of 1 Peter 1: 3, born again. (51).

Biblically and theologically, the new birth, to beget again, being born again equates to regeneration.

In the atonement, sanctification equates to holiness. Sanctification is also literally "being set apart" by God. (807). Being sanctified is being made holy (807). This is a process of growth, that is not culminated as immediate, as are some other aspects of the applied atoning and resurrection work of Jesus Christ. Cited from The Orthodox Study Bible, New Testament and Psalms, (1993) Saint Athanasius Orthodox Academy, Thomas Nelson Publishers, Nashville, Tennessee.

'Moral uprightness' is not the same as holiness, as holiness equates to sanctification, whereas, being moral and upright is somewhat theologically ambiguous, based on my Bloesch citation. This may or may not connect to divine atonement and justification and righteousness in Christ. Both the regenerate and unregenerate could have levels of 'moral uprightness'.
 

AUGUSTINE (388-395)(1964) On Free Choice of the Will, Translated by Anna S.Benjamin and L.H. Hackstaff, Upper Saddle River, N.J., Prentice-Hall.         

AUGUSTINE (398-399)(1992) Confessions, Translated by Henry Chadwick, Oxford, Oxford University Press. 

AUGUSTINE (400-416)(1987)(2004) On the Trinity, Translated by Reverend Arthur West Haddan, in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Series One, Volume 3, Denver, The Catholic Encyclopedia. 

AUGUSTINE (421)(1998) Enchiridion, Translated by J.F. Shaw,  Denver, The Catholic Encyclopedia. 

AUGUSTINE (426)(1958) The City of God, Translated by Gerald G. Walsh, Garden City, New York, Image Books. 

AUGUSTINE (427)(1997) On Christian Doctrine, Translated by D.W. Robertson Jr., Upper Saddle River, N.J., Prentice-Hall. 

AUGUSTINE (427b)(1997) On Christian Teaching, Translated by R.P.H. Green, Oxford, Oxford University Press. 

BAUER, WALTER. (1979) A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, Translated by Eric H. Wahlstrom, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press. 

BAVINCK, HERMAN (1918)(2006) Reformed Dogmatics Volume 2: God and Creation, John Bolt (gen.ed.), Translated by John Vriend, Baker Academic, Grand Rapids.

BAVINCK, HERMAN (1918)(2006) Reformed Dogmatics Volume 3: Sin and Salvation in Christ, John Bolt (gen.ed.), Translated by John Vriend, Baker Academic, Grand Rapids.

BLOESCH, DONALD G. (1987) Freedom for Obedience, San Francisco, Harper and Rowe Publishers.  

BLOESCH, DONALD G. (1996) ‘Sin, The Biblical Understanding of Sin’, in Walter A. Elwell (ed.), Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Books.  

CALVIN, JOHN (1539)(1998) The Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book II, Translated by Henry Beveridge, Grand Rapids, The Christian Classic Ethereal Library, Wheaton College. 

CALVIN, JOHN (1539)(1998) The Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book IV, Translated by Henry Beveridge, Grand Rapids, The Christian Classic Ethereal Library, Wheaton College. 

CALVIN, JOHN (1543)(1996) The Bondage and Liberation of the Will, Translated by G.I. Davies, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House. 

COURSON, JON (2005) Application Commentary, Thomas Nelson, Nashville. 

GRENZ, STANLEY J. DAVID GURETZKI and CHERITH FEE NORDLING (1999) Pocket Dictionary of Theological Terms, Downers Grove, Ill., InterVarsity Press. 

MARTENS, ELMER A. (1990) God’s Design: A Focus on Old Testament Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House. 

NUTE, ALAN G. (1986) in 'Titus', The International Bible Commentary, F.F. Bruce, General Editor, Grand Rapids, Zondervan/Marshall Pickering.

SCHRECK, ALAN (1984) Catholic and Christian, Ann Arbor, Michigan, Servant Books. WHALE, J.S. (1958) Christian Doctrine, Glasgow, Fontana Books. 

SHEDD, WILLIAM G.T. (1874-1890)(1980) Dogmatic Theology, Volume 1, Nashville, Thomas Nelson Publishers. 

SHEDD, WILLIAM G.T. (1874-1890)(1980) Dogmatic Theology, Volume 2, Nashville, Thomas Nelson Publishers. 

STRONG, J. (1890)(1986) Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible, Pickering, Ontario, Welch Publishing Company. 

The Orthodox Study Bible, New Testament and Psalms, (1993) Saint Athanasius Orthodox Academy, Thomas Nelson Publishers, Nashville, Tennessee.

WEBER, OTTO (1955)(1981) Foundations of Dogmatics, Volumes 1 and 2, Translated and annotated by Darrell L. Guder, William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company.


Saturday, June 15, 2024

J.S. Whale (Wales PhD Edit)

Munich-Facebook
J.S. Whale (Wales PhD Edit)

Preface

This is selected PhD material that cites the work of J.S. Whale (John Sheldon). Originally published 20131015. I noticed that I did not include the full footnotes originally. This article will be republished 20240615.

Note that my writing for my PhD was completed within the rules, regulations and standards of British academia. This work is not primarily a series of my theological and philosophical views, although included in places.

2010 Theodicy and Practical Theology: PhD thesis, the University of Wales, Trinity Saint David, Lampeter 

Saturday, September 19, 2020: PhD Full Version PDF: Theodicy and Practical Theology 2010, Wales TSD
_____________________________________

The Bible

J.S. Whale (1958) explains that within Protestant thought the Bible represents the whole counsel of God and nothing can be added whether by new revelation or tradition.[1]  Whale, however, correctly warns against the idea of the Bible becoming a law book,[2] and the Scripture needs to stay a historical living word as opposed to a narrow book of rules.[3] This goes back to Erickson’s point that God’s word, although an unchanging message must be interpreted for each era.[4] This in no way allows for an overhaul of major, traditional Christian doctrines from traditional and Reformed perspectives,[5] but with the use of practical and empirical approaches there would be opportunities to understand Christian theology in modern terms.[6]  In other words, the very same Biblical doctrines that were given in the contexts of ancient Israel, Europe, Asia, and Africa need to be explained in the contexts of twenty-first century Western civilization, and other societies in the world. Theological principles would remain the same, but theological application can vary within eras and locations.[7]

Infant baptism 

Whale reasons infant baptism demonstrates that Christ did something for a person, without waiting for human approval.[8] Rebaptism[9] would never be needed as although baptized Roman Catholics can turn from the faith, if they do turn back to Christ the initial baptism is sufficient.[10] The sacrament of infant baptism is one of the ‘foundational stones of Church.’[11]  Klein, Blomberg and Hubbard reason it is not Biblically clear what type of baptism should be practiced.[12] Infant baptism is not taught in Scripture directly,[13] and therefore it can be deduced the same could be stated for the associated concepts of baptismal regeneration with Roman Catholics[14] and Eastern Orthodox[15] Churches. However, legitimate theological inference leads to concepts of infant baptism,[16] and so there are also historical arguments for baptismal regeneration within the Christian community which includes Catholic,[17]  Eastern Orthodox,[18] and even in some cases Presbyterian,[19] Lutheran and Episcopal.[20]

The Resurrection 

Whale writes that the resurrection is not to be considered an addition to the Christian faith, but is the Christian faith.[21]  Theologian Robert B. Sloan (1991) reasons that for early Christians the resurrection vindicated Christ in regard to his detractors and gave his message authority.[22] Jürgen Moltmann writes that as the crucified one, the risen Christ is available for humanity.[23] Moltmann explains to some the resurrection of Christ is a counter to the abandonment of humanity of God while Christ was on the cross.[24]  For certain observers Christ’s resurrection for all turns them from atheism.[25] This may be because the historical resurrection of Christ would be viewed as God actually participating in the world to remedy the problem of evil.[26] God would not only be judging the world as he did on the cross,[27] but actually bringing about resolution to the problem of evil through Christ[28] and from a human perspective this makes a belief and trust in the Biblical God reasonable and worthwhile. 

Transcendence 

J.S. Whale explains transcendence makes God inaccessible and unknowable to finite creatures.[29] For Whale, Christ revealed the nature of the transcendent God in his life and ministry.[30] According to Kreeft and Tacelli, God is not part of the physical universe, and is not limited by the universe.[31] God is the creator of the universe and all things, and is ‘other’ than the universe.[32]

Expiation/Propitiation

Whale writes that expiation means God himself purges or covers human sin.[33] To state that Christ expiates sin[34] means that his atoning work enables God to forgive sins[35] and gradually, and eventually, purge sinfulness out of obedient followers.[36] Palma explains that some argue propitiation must be rejected in favour of expiation, since propitiation and its divine wrath is a concept that comes from pagan origins where pagan deities were appeased through sacrifice.[37] He reasons that within the New Testament, propitiation includes the idea of expiation, but expiation does not necessarily include the idea of propitiation.[38]  James Strong explains that the word under review in Romans 3: 25, hilasterion, (ἱλαστήριον) is defined as an expiatory place or thing, an ‘atoning victim’ along with ‘mercyseat’ and ‘propitiation.’[39] This definition, although somewhat vague[40] does not contradict Palma’s concept that propitiation does include the idea of expiation.[41] From Strong’s definition, Romans 3: 25 does perhaps allow for the idea of atonement in both the sense of sacrifice and appeasement.[42] However, his definition does place more emphasis on expiation than propitiation in the atonement process in Romans 3: 25.[43]

Walter Bauer writes that the meaning in Romans 3: 25 is uncertain and could be either expiates or propitiates.[44] According to Strong the definition of the word from 1 John 2:2 and 4:10 is ‘atonement’ along with ‘expiator’ and ‘propitiation’ and so 1 John does not solve the issue from Romans.[45] Since this thesis is primarily concerned with theodicy and atonement is a secondary, but important issue, let me conclude by stating that the Greek word allows for discussion and various interpretation.[46] Some within liberal, progressive Christian traditions may insist that expiation is all that is required within the atoning work of Christ;[47] while others such as myself, within moderate conservative traditions may conclude expiation and propitiation, both sacrifice and appeasement are reasonable concepts within Christian atonement.[48]

Suffering/Death 

Whale writes creation has an ultimate meaning that is not disclosed until the end where the final purpose becomes clear.[49]  Death is the ultimate end of temporal suffering and Whale reasons that natural phenomenon does not completely explain it as human beings are not purely natural, but also posses God’s image.[50] It seems, from a traditional Christian perspective, that in death, resurrection and judgment, the plan symbol[51] of God finally culminates. According to Moltmann, through the history of the crucified and risen Christ, lies the consummation of the Kingdom of God that sets things free and provides them with meaning.[52]

Vicarious Suffering

Specifically, the term ‘vicarious’ is usually, within Christian theology, used in the context of atonement and means ‘in the place of’[53] and that Christ died in the place of sinful humanity. [54]  Whale reasons ‘vicarious suffering’ consists of one taking suffering for another.[55] 

Cosmology 

Whale writes that cosmology is looking at the cosmos and visible universe from a theistic perspective denying that it is self-explanatory.[56] Pojman mentions that theistic versions of cosmology deduce something outside of the universe is required to explain its existence.[57] Paul Edwards (1973) explains cosmology reasons that all things come into being through other things,[58] and since a causal series of events cannot go back in infinity, there must be a first cause.[59] Thomas Aquinas is famous for discussing The Five Ways and his cosmological argument within Summa Theologica.[60] Plantinga reasons that aspects of Aquinas’ presentation[61] are reasonable, but overall the argument is unsuccessful.[62] I reason this does not render all arguments for first cause unsuccessful, but Plantinga points out difficulties with Aquinas’ approach,[63] which is perhaps too extensive.[64] Edwards comments[65] would adequately explain a more modest and reasonable idea concerning first cause.[66] 

_____________________

[1] Whale (1958: 15).

[2] Whale (1958: 15).

[3] Whale (1958: 15).

[4] Erickson (1994: 37).

[5] Whale (1958: 15).

[6] Pattison and Woodward (2000)(2007: 14-15).

[7] Whale (1958: 15).  Erickson (1994: 37).

[8] Whale (1958: 158).

[9] Or Believer’s Baptism as it is known within Baptist and Anabaptist theology.

[10] Schreck (1984: 129). 

[11] Whale (1958: 158). Whale does not view infant baptism as mere dedication or as a rite effecting regeneration and so his position is not identical to Schreck’s, although he does support the sacrament being practiced.

[12] Klein, Blomberg, and Hubbard (1993: 140).

[13] Klein, Blomberg, and Hubbard (1993: 140).

[14] Schreck (1984: 124). 

[15] Kavanagh (1999: 300).

[16] Klein, Blomberg, and Hubbard (1993: 140).

[17] Schreck (1984: 124). 

[18] Kavanagh (1999: 300).

[19] John Calvin raised the possibility that in some cases baptismal regeneration could take place in infants.  Calvin (1539)(1998: Book IV, Chapter 14, 17-20). There are some Presbyterians that take this view.  However, I am a member of a Presbyterian Church in America that believes in infant baptism, but not in baptismal regeneration.  

[20] Kavanagh (1999: 300).  In Lutheran theology infant baptism and baptismal regeneration must be accompanied by the faith of the parents or future faith of the infant at a more mature age.  Some Lutherans and Presbyterians would reject any concept of baptismal regeneration.  Grenz, Guretzki, and Nordling (1999: 19).

[21] Whale (1958: 69).

[22] Sloan (1991: 449).

[23] Moltmann (1993: 195).

[24] Moltmann (1993: 195).

[25] Moltmann (1993: 195).

[26] Others such as Darrow, Phillips, and Flew would be very skeptical of this concept.  Phillips (2005: 247-275).  Darrow (1928)(1973: 266-267).  Flew (1983)(1996: 92). If one does not believe in the resurrection of Christ, God’s key witness to the world that he wishes to save it from the problem of evil is gone.  The remedy to sin and death would be non-existent and therefore concepts of a perfected world far-fetched.

[27] Moltmann (1993: 195).

[28] Moltmann (1993: 195).

[29] Whale (1958: 56).

[30] Whale (1958: 109).

[31] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 93).

[32] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 93).

[33] Whale (1958: 81).

[34] Whale (1958: 81).

[35] Whale (1958: 81).

[36] Whale (1958: 81).

[37] Palma (2007: 1).

[38] Palma (2007: 1).

[39] Strong (1890)(1986: 48).

[40] Strong (1890)(1986: 48).

[41] Palma (2007: 1).

[42] Strong (1890)(1986: 48).

[43] Strong (1890)(1986: 48).

[44] Bauer (1979: 375).

[45] Strong (1890)(1986: 49).

[46] Palma (2007: 1).

[47] Dodd (1935: 82-95).

[48] Erickson (1994: 809-810).  Strong (1890)(1986: 48).  Bauer (1979: 375).

[49] Whale (1958: 164).

[50] Whale (1958: 166).

[51] van der Ven (1993: 173).  van der Ven (1998: 212-213).

[52] Moltmann (1993: 338).

[53] Grenz, Guretzki, and Nordling (1999: 120).

[54] Grenz, Guretzki, and Nordling (1999: 120).

[55] Whale (1958: 81-82).

[56] Whale (1958: 22).

[57] Pojman (1996: 37).

[58] Edwards (1973: 377-378).

[59] Edwards (1973: 377-378).

[60] Aquinas, Thomas (1261)(1920) Summa Theologica, Translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province, London, Fathers of the English Dominican Province.

[61] Aquinas, Thomas (1261)(1920).

[62] Plantinga (1977)(2002: 80).

[63] Aquinas, Thomas (1261)(1920).

[64] Aquinas’ presentation although classic and important, is very speculative and Plantinga has disagreements with his overall work.  Plantinga (1977)(2002: 80). Geivett reasons Plantinga is too negative concerning natural theology as possibly working.  Geivett (1993: 59-60). 

[65] Edwards (1973: 377-378).

[66] Grenz and Olson (1992: 16).

____________________

AQUINAS, THOMAS (1261)(1920) Summa Theologica, Translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province, London, Fathers of the English Dominican Province. 

BAUER, WALTER. (1979) A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, Translated by Eric H. Wahlstrom, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.

BROMILEY, G.W. (1996) ‘Baptism, Infant’, in Walter A. Elwell (ed.), Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Books.

BROWNING, W.R.F. (1997) ‘Propitiation' in Oxford Dictionary of the Bible, Oxford, Oxford University Press. 

CALVIN, JOHN (1539)(1998) The Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book II, Translated by Henry Beveridge, Grand Rapids, The Christian Classic Ethereal Library, Wheaton College.Christian Classic Ethereal Library, Wheaton College. http://www.ccel.org/ccel/calvin/institutes.html  

CALVIN, JOHN (1539)(1998) The Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book IV, Translated by Henry Beveridge, Grand Rapids, The Christian Classic Ethereal Library, Wheaton College.http://www.ccel.org/ccel/calvin/institutes.html  

CALVIN, JOHN (1540)(1973) Romans and Thessalonians, Translated by Ross Mackenzie, Grand Rapids, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company.  

CALVIN, JOHN (1543)(1996) The Bondage and Liberation of the Will, Translated by G.I. Davies, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House.  

CALVIN, JOHN (1550)(1978) Concerning Scandals, Translated by John W. Fraser, Grand Rapids, William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company.  

CALVIN, JOHN (1552)(1995) Acts, Translated by Watermark, Nottingham, Crossway Books.  

CALVIN, JOHN (1553)(1952) Job, Translated by Leroy Nixon, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House.  

CALVIN, JOHN (1554)(1965) Genesis, Translated by John King, Edinburgh, The Banner of Truth Trust. 

CRANFIELD, C.E.B. (1992) Romans: A Shorter Commentary, Grand Rapids, William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company.  

EDWARDS, PAUL AND ARTHUR PAP (1973)(eds.), A Modern Introduction To Philosophy, New York, The Free Press. 

ERICKSON, MILLARD (1994) Christian Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House. 

ERICKSON, MILLARD (2003) What Does God Know and When Does He Know It?  Grand Rapids, Zondervan. 

DARROW, CLARENCE (1928)(1973) ‘The Myth of the Soul’ in The Forum, October, in Paul Edwards and Arthur Pap (eds), A Modern Introduction To Philosophy, New York, The Free Press.

DODD. C.H. (1935) The Bible and the Greeks, London, Hodder and Stoughton. 

FLEW, ANTONY, R.M. HARE, AND BASIL MITCHELL (1983) (1996) ‘The Debate on the Rationality of Religious Belief’, in L.P. Pojman (ed.), Philosophy, The Quest for Truth, New York, Wadsworth Publishing Company.

GEIVETT, R. DOUGLAS (1993) Evil and the Evidence for God, Philadelphia, Temple University Press. 

GRENZ, STANLEY J., DAVID GURETZKI AND CHERITH FEE NORDLING (1999) Pocket Dictionary of Theological Terms, Downers Grove, Ill., InterVarsity Press. 

GRENZ, STANLEY J. AND ROGER E. OLSON (1992) Twentieth Century Theology, Downer’s Grove, Illinois, InterVarsity Press.  

KAVANAGH, AIDAN (1999) ‘Initiation, Christian’,  in Alan Richardson and John Bowden (eds.), A New Dictionary of Christian Theology, Kent, SCM Press Ltd.  

KLEIN, WILLIAM W., CRAIG, C. BLOMBERG, AND ROBERT L. HUBBARD, JR. (1993) Introduction to Biblical Interpretation, London, Word Publishing. 

KREEFT, PETER (1988) Fundamentals of the Faith, San Francisco, Ignatius Press.  

KREEFT, PETER AND RONALD K. TACELLI (1994) Handbook of Christian Apologetics, Downers Grove, Illinois, InterVarsity Press.

LINDSELL, HAROLD (1976) The Battle for the Bible, Grand Rapids, Zondervan Publishing House.

MOLTMANN, JÜRGEN (1993) The Crucified God, Minneapolis, Fortress Press. 

MOUNCE, ROBERT H. (1995) The New American Commentary: Romans, Nashville, Broadman & Holman Publishers.

PALMA, ANTHONY (2007) ‘Propitiation’ in Enrichment Journal, Springfield Missouri, Enrichment Journal.http://enrichmentjournal.ag.org/top/Easter_2007/2007_Propitiation.pdf  

PHILLIPS, D.Z. (2005) The Problem of Evil and the Problem of God, Fortress Press, Minneapolis.

PLANTINGA, ALVIN C. (1977)(2002) God, Freedom, and Evil, Grand Rapids, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. 

PLANTINGA, ALVIN C. (1982) The Nature of Necessity, Oxford, Clarendon Press. 

PLANTINGA, ALVIN C. (2000) Warranted Christian Belief, Oxford, Oxford University Press. 

POJMAN, LOUIS P. (1996) Philosophy: The Quest for Truth, New York, Wadsworth Publishing Company.

SCHRECK, ALAN (1984) Catholic and Christian, Ann Arbor, Michigan, Servant Books. 

SLOAN, ROBERT B (1991) ‘Unity in Diversity’, in David Alan Black and David S. Dockery (eds.), New Testament Criticism and Interpretation, Grand Rapids, Zondervan Publishing House. 

STRONG, J. (1986) Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible, Pickering, Ontario, Welch Publishing Company.

THIESSEN, HENRY C. (1956) Introductory Lectures in Systematic Theology, Grand Rapids, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. 

VAN DER VEN, JOHANNES (1993) Practical Theology, Translated by Barbara Schultz, AC Kampen, Netherlands, Kok Pharos Publishing House. 

VAN DER VEN, JOHANNES (1998) God Reinvented?, Leiden, Brill.  

VAN DER VEN, JOHANNES (2005) ‘Theodicy Items and Scheme’, in a personal email from Johannes van der Ven, Nijmegen, Radboud University, Nijmegen.  

VAN DER VEN, JOHANNES (2006a) ‘Dates of Nijmegen authors’, in a personal email from Johannes van der Ven, Nijmegen, Radboud University, Nijmegen.  

VAN DER VEN, JOHANNES (2006b) ‘Symbols versus Models’, in a personal email from Johannes van der Ven, Nijmegen, Radboud University, Nijmegen. 

VAN DER VEN, JOHANNES, PAUL VERMEER, AND ERIC VOSSEN (1996) ‘Learning Theodicy’, in Journal of Empirical Theology, Volume 9, pp. 67-85. Kampen, The Netherlands, Journal of Empirical Theology.  

VAN DER VEN, JOHANNES AND ERIC VOSSEN (1996) Suffering: Why for God’s Sake? Grand Rapids, Eerdmans.  

WHALE, J.S. (1958) Christian Doctrine, Glasgow, Fontana Books.  

WOODWARD, JAMES AND STEPHEN PATTISON (2000)(2007)(eds.), The Blackwell Reader in Pastoral and Practical Theology, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing.