 |
| York: scan |
MPhil, Bangor University, 2003: The Problem of Evil: Anglican and Baptist Perspectives
PhD, University of Wales, Trinity Saint David, Lampeter, 2010: Theodicy and Practical Theology
From MPhil 2003
C.S. Lewis notes that there is a paradox concerning tribulation in Christianity. Lewis makes a good point, that God uses evil for the greater good but human disobedience to God is still sin. He stated: "Now the fact God can make complex good out of simple evil does not excuse--though by mercy it may save--those who do the simple evil." Lewis (l940)(1996: 111).
God can use evil for the betterment of his creation overall, but this does not change his character, and those who oppose his will still sin because their motives are not good as are God’s. However, God remains non-sinful and thus not a contradictory being.
John Calvin had stated:
Then we shall understand that God is not made the author of evil deeds when he said to lead the ungodly where he wills and to accomplish and execute his work through them, but rather we shall acknowledge that he is a wonderfully expert craftsman who can use even bad tools well. We shall be compelled to admire his justice, which not only finds a way through iniquity but also employs that very iniquity to a good end. Calvin (1543) (1996: 40).
So, from the words of both Lewis and Calvin, the idea is being put forward that God is in ultimate, but not robotic control of his creation. His creation sins against God with anti-God motives, and thus are guilty of crimes against him. God, however, is still able to use these evil works for the greater good.
This means that tribulation, although largely caused by sins of human beings, and perhaps at times, fallen angels, is still being used by God for his final purposes of good. Since tribulation is necessary in redemption, then it will not stop until the world is fully redeemed or no longer seen as redeemable. Lewis’ point here was that social improvements were good, but they were not the ultimate answer. He stated: "I am only reminding the reader that a particular medicine is not to be mistaken for the elixir of life." Lewis (1940)(1996: 115). Lewis stated that reform from the hands of humanity can only bring so much good, but that a heaven on earth can only take place through God’s direct intervention through Christ.
CALVIN,J.(1539)(1998) Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book II.
CALVIN, J. (1543)(1998) The Bondage and Liberation of the Will, Translated by G.I. Davies, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House.
CALVIN, J. (1553)(1952) Job, Translated by Leroy Nixon, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House.
LEWIS, C.S. (1961)(1983) A Grief Observed, London, Faber and Faber.
LEWIS, C.S. (1941)(1990) The Screwtape Letters, Uhrichsville, Ohio, Barbour and Company.
LEWIS, C.S. (1940)(1996) The Problem of Pain, San Francisco, Harper-Collins.
