Showing posts sorted by relevance for query baptism. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query baptism. Sort by date Show all posts

Saturday, August 25, 2007

Some thoughts on infant baptism


Kenora, Ontario (photo from trekearth.com)

A few weeks ago after church outside in the park, a friendly debate took place concerning the merits of infant baptism, also known as paedobaptism. I have never been convinced that it is the standard Biblical practice of baptism, and was taught at Columbia Bible College (Mennonite), and Canadian Baptist Seminary at Trinity Western University that believer’s baptism was the standard Biblical practice. This is complex subject, and one that I admit I am not a scholar, although in this article I will provide some information in an academic and scholarly manner. This will not be an overly long, exhaustive article, as those types of articles do not work well in a blog context! Having become a member of the Presbyterian Church in America (North America) I do admit that infant baptism does have theological strengths even if I suppose that believer’s baptism has a stronger case. Frankly, I reason that this is an important issue, but, and I say this humbly, I think that there are far more important issues for Christians to be debating, such as free will and sovereignty theodicy!

On a personal note, I was baptized/christened as an infant in the United Church of Canada, and as an adult in the Mennonite Brethren Church with full immersion. I view the United Church as very liberal and my initial experience as questionable. Comments for this article, as always, are appreciated.

G.W. Bromiley, who as of 1996 was Senior Professor of Church History and Historical Theology at Fuller Theological Seminary, explains that in early church history those such as Irenaeus and Origen, who were close to the apostles, were involved in baptizing children of professing believers. Bromiley (1996: 116). Infant Baptism was performed somewhat on Scriptural grounds, although there is no direct Biblical command to baptize infants. Bromiley (1996: 116). Bromiley reasons that although in Acts there were household baptisms, there are no clear-cut instances of child baptism. Bromiley (1996: 116). Bromiley thinks Biblically and theologically that there is evidence that infant baptism should be the normal practice in families where the gospel has taken hold, although there is no guarantee that children shall be believers. Bromiley (1996: 116).

Bromiley writes that many view believer’s baptism as the only legitimate New Testament form of baptism, although not necessarily immersion. Bromiley (1996: 114). He explains that many tie in Christ’s call to baptize with the idea of making disciples, and nothing was said about infants. Bromiley (1996: 114). The question arises if infants are disciples, and I would think not, although they certainly can be disciples in waiting. Bromiley notes that from Paul’s writings that tie belief and repentance with baptism it does not make sense to baptize infants that cannot hear the gospel or make a response of belief. Christ’s love for children is evident, but there is no direct Biblical command to include them in the baptism process, and there is no Biblical warrant to suppose that baptism should definitely precede belief and repentance. Bromiley (1996: 115). Bromiley admits that the households in Acts may have included infants, but even if there were, there is no indication that they were baptized and states that it would be hazardous inference to use these verses to support infant baptism. Bromiley (1996: 115). Bromiley writes that the need for faith is correctly found in infant baptism, but that the personal confession found in Believer’s baptism is stronger. Bromiley (1996: 115).

Reading Bromiley, it seems he reasons that it is good for infants within a Christian family to receive baptism, but that it would be even better for them to have believer’s baptism at a later date.

To conclude, here are some thoughts on Colossians 2:11-12 which is a section of the New Testament often used to support infant baptism.

Roman Catholic support of the idea from Robert H. Brom.

http://www.catholic.com/library/Infant_Baptism.asp

In Place of Circumcision

Furthermore, Paul notes that baptism has replaced circumcision (Col. 2:11–12). In that passage, he refers to baptism as "the circumcision of Christ" and "the circumcision made without hands." Of course, usually only infants were circumcised under the Old Law; circumcision of adults was rare, since there were few converts to Judaism. If Paul meant to exclude infants, he would not have chosen circumcision as a parallel for baptism.

This comparison between who could receive baptism and circumcision is an appropriate one. In the Old Testament, if a man wanted to become a Jew, he had to believe in the God of Israel and be circumcised. In the New Testament, if one wants to become a Christian, one must believe in God and Jesus and be baptized. In the Old Testament, those born into Jewish households could be circumcised in anticipation of the Jewish faith in which they would be raised. Thus in the New Testament, those born in Christian households can be baptized in anticipation of the Christian faith in which they will be raised. The pattern is the same: If one is an adult, one must have faith before receiving the rite of membership; if one is a child too young to have faith, one may be given the rite of membership in the knowledge that one will be raised in the faith. This is the basis of Paul’s reference to baptism as "the circumcision of Christ"—that is, the Christian equivalent of circumcision.


Support for the concept from R. Scott Clark of Westminster Theological Seminary

http://public.csusm.edu/guests/rsclark/Infant_Baptism.html

What is the Connection Between Circumcision and Baptism?
The connection between baptism and circumcision is quite clear in Colossians 2:11-12. The connection is not direct, but indirect and the point of contact between them is Christ and baptism is the sign and seal of that circumcision. In v.11 Paul says "in him [i.e. in Christ] you were also circumcised with the circumcision done by Christ" and in v.12 he says exactly how it is that we were circumcised in and by Christ: "having been buried with him in baptism and raised with him through your faith...." For Paul, in the New covenant, our union with Christ is our circumcision. In baptism, we are identified with Christ's baptism/circumcision, as it were, on the cross. Neither baptism nor circumcision effects this union (ex opere operato), rather God the Spirit unites us to Christ, makes us alive and gives us faith.

The point not to be missed is that, in Paul's mind, baptism and circumcision are both signs and seals of Christ's baptism/circumcision on the cross for us. By faith, we are united to Christ's circumcision and by union with Christ we become participants in his circumcision/baptism. Because circumcision pointed forward to Christ's death and baptism looks back to Christ's death, they are closely linked in Paul's mind and almost interchangeable. Paul's point here is to teach us about our union with Christ, but along the way we see how he thinks about baptism and circumcision and his thinking should inform ours.

One of the reasons that Paul so strongly opposed the imposition of circumcision upon Christians by the Judaizers is that, by faith, we have already been circumcised in Christ, of which baptism is the sign and seal. We were already identified as belonging to God and we have undergone the curse in Christ. So actual physical circumcision is, in the new covenant, unnecessary. Paul tells those who wish to circumcise themselves, to go the whole way and emasculate themselves.

Acts 2.38,39 equates circumcision and baptism. In Acts 2.38 the Apostle Peter calls for repentance, faith in Christ and baptism by Jews who are hearing his preaching. In v.39 he gives the reason for this action: "the promise is to you and to your children, and all who are far off...." The Apostle Peter consciously uses the same formula in his preaching as the LORD himself used when he instituted the sign of circumcision in Genesis 17, which the Jews listening understood precisely.

Richard C. Barcellos explains the view that spiritual circumcision and not baptism, replaces physical circumcision.

http://www.reformedreader.org/RBTRII.1.Col.2.Barcellos.RPM.doc

Baptism does not replace circumcision as the sign and seal of the covenant. We have seen clearly that spiritual circumcision, not baptism, replaces physical circumcision. Baptism in Col. 2:12 (i.e., vital union with Christ) is a result of spiritual circumcision. Burial and resurrection with Christ is not equivalent to but causally subsequent to spiritual circumcision. Physical circumcision has been replaced by spiritual circumcision under the New Covenant. The correspondence between the two, however, is not one-to-one. Paul tells us this by saying that New Covenant circumcision is “a circumcision made without hands.” Though physical circumcision and spiritual circumcision are related they are not equivalent. One is physical and does not affect the heart; the other is spiritual and does not affect the body. Both are indications of covenant membership. But only the circumcision of the heart guarantees one’s eternal destiny, for all the regenerate express faith and “are protected by the power of God through faith” (1 Pet. 1:5).

We must take issue with those who argue from this text that baptism replaces circumcision. The Lutheran scholar Eduard Lohse asserts, “Baptism is called circumcision here… The circumcision of Christ which every member of the community has experienced is nothing other than being baptized into the death and resurrection of Christ.” We have seen, however, that the only replacement motif in this text is between physical circumcision and spiritual circumcision. Spiritual circumcision is not equivalent to baptism. Baptism (i.e. union with Christ) is the sphere in which burial and resurrection with Christ occurs, which is effected through faith, and a result of spiritual circumcision.

The Reformed commentator William Hendriksen says:

Evidently Paul in this entire paragraph magnifies Christian baptism as much as he, by clear implication, disapproves of the continuation of the rite of circumcision if viewed as having anything to do with salvation. The definite implication, therefore, is that baptism has taken the place of circumcision. Hence, what is said with reference to circumcision in Rom. 4:11, as being a sign and a seal, holds also for baptism. In the Colossian context baptism is specifically a sign and seal of having been buried with Christ and of having been raised with him [emphasis Hendriksen’s].

We take issue with Hendriksen’s view on several fronts. First, Paul is not magnifying Christian baptism in this text. He is magnifying Christian circumcision. This is evident by the fact that “you were also circumcised” is the regulating verb to which the rest of vv. 11 and 12 are subordinate. Second, there is not a “definite implication …that baptism has taken the place of circumcision.” Our exegesis has shown us this clearly. Third, it is not true that “what is said with reference to circumcision in Rom. 4:11, as being a sign and a seal, holds also for baptism.” This is so because Paul is not arguing for a replacement theology between physical circumcision and water baptism and because the seal of the New Covenant is the Holy Spirit (Eph. 1:13; 4:30). Fourth, Paul says nothing in Col. 2:11-12 about baptism being “a sign and seal of having been buried with Christ and of having been raised with him.” He does say that the subsequent, spiritual concomitant of spiritual circumcision is spiritual burial and resurrection with Christ in baptism effected through faith. There is no hint of baptism being a sign and seal as argued by Hendriksen. It is of interest to note one of Hendriksen’s footnotes to these statements. Notice the concession he makes.

I am speaking here about a clear implication. The surface contrast is that between literal circumcision and circumcision without hands, namely, the circumcision of the heart, as explained. But the implication also is clear. Hence, the following statement is correct: “Since, then, baptism has come in the place of circumcision (Col. 2:11-13), the children should be baptized as heirs of the kingdom of God and of his covenant” (Form for the Baptism of Infants in Psalter Hymnal of the Christian Reformed Church, Grand Rapids, Mich., 1959, p. 86). When God made his covenant with Abraham the children were included (Gen. 17:1-14). This covenant, in its spiritual aspects, was continued in the present dispensation (Acts 2:38, 29; Rom. 4:9-12; Gal. 3:7, 8, 29). Therefore the children are still included and should still receive the sign, which in the present dispensation, as Paul makes clear in Col. 2:11, 12, is baptism [emphases Hendriksen’s].

Hendriksen’s concession that “The surface contrast is that between literal circumcision and circumcision without hands” surely sheds doubt over his initial claim of “speaking here about a clear implication.” Again, we have seen that Paul is not arguing that water baptism replaces physical circumcision as a sign and seal of the covenant. It does not follow, then, that “the children should be baptized as heirs of the kingdom of God and of his covenant.” Paul does not say or imply that the sign of the covenant is baptism. Instead, the sign of the covenant is regeneration. All who are spiritually circumcised are immediately buried and raised with Christ in baptism, effected through faith. Colossians 2:11-12 is about the application of redemption to elect souls and does not imply infant baptism, some of which are not elect. If it implies anything about water baptism, it implies that it ought to be administered to those who have been circumcised of heart and vitally united to Christ through faith as a symbol of these spiritual blessings.

All who are circumcised of heart are buried and raised with Christ through faith immediately subsequent to their heart circumcision. Regeneration cannot be abstracted from its immediate fruits. All regenerate souls are immediately untied to Christ through faith. This is what Col. 2:11-12 clearly teaches. Our exegesis argues for an ordo salutus as follows: regeneration, then union with Christ through faith. And this experience is that of all the regenerate and has nothing to do with the act of water baptism in itself.

This text neither teaches baptismal regeneration nor implies infant baptism. In context, it is displaying the completeness believers have in Christ. It does not apply to unbelievers or to all who are baptized by any mode and by properly recognized ecclesiastical administrators. It has to do with the spiritual realities that come to souls who are Christ’s sheep. It has to do with the application of redemption to elect sinners. It has to do with regeneration, faith, and experiential union with Christ. These are the aspects of completeness in Christ Paul highlights here. We should gain much encouragement from these things. They were revealed to fortify believers against error. They were written to strengthen saints already in Christ. They were not revealed as proof for the subjects of baptism. They were not revealed to teach us that water baptism replaces physical circumcision as the sign and seal of the covenant. God gave us Col. 2:11-12 to display this fact: When you have Jesus, you have all you need!

BARCELLOS, RICHARD C. (2007) An Exegetical Appraisal of Colossians 2:11-12, Escondido, California, The Reformed Reader.
http://www.reformedreader.org/RBTRII.1.Col.2.Barcellos.RPM.doc

BROM, ROBERT H. (2005) Infant Baptism, El Cajon, California, Catholic Answers.
http://www.catholic.com/library/Infant_Baptism.asp

BROMILEY, G.W. (1996) ‘Baptism, Infant', in Walter A. Elwell (ed.), Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Books.

CLARK, R. SCOTT (2005) A Contemporary Reformed Defense of Infant Baptism, Escondido, California, Westminster Theological Seminary.
http://public.csusm.edu/guests/rsclark/Infant_Baptism.html


Monday, November 07, 2016

Baptism Revisited

Immaculate Conception Parish, Delta, BC

Infant Baptism August 2007

Saturday Part One

It was a busy weekend for me. I officially signed as a member of Northview Community Church on Sunday.

On Saturday, I attended the wedding of a Mennonite friend that also attends my former Presbyterian church.

An interesting discussion arose with myself and two leaders from my former Reformed Presbyterian church which is paedobaptist (infant baptism) in theology, in regard to my new Anabaptist church, which takes the believer's baptism stance.

Therefore, not to reinvent the wheel, I will rework my excerpts from my 2007 article and as usual in these contexts, add new material.

On a personal note, I was baptized/christened as an infant in the United Church of Canada, and as an adult in the Mennonite Brethren Church with full immersion. I view the United Church as very liberal and my initial experience as questionable, although I admit I was taught the gospel as a child at the United Church. Particularly in Sunday school. This is credit where credit is due.

While I was a member at the Presbyterian church, I had friendly discussions with leaders, and I accept their claim appears true that at least two of the Church Fathers, 'disciples of disciples' to quote a lead Pastor, practiced infant baptism.

Bromiley

G.W. Bromiley, who as of 1996 was Senior Professor of Church History and Historical Theology at Fuller Theological Seminary, explains that in early church history those such as Irenaeus and Origen, who were close to the apostles, were involved in baptizing children of professing believers. Bromiley (1996: 116). Infant Baptism was performed somewhat on Scriptural grounds, although there is no direct Biblical command to baptize infants. Bromiley (1996: 116).

Bromiley reasons that although in Acts there were household baptisms, there are no clear-cut instances of child baptism. Bromiley (1996: 116). He thinks Biblically and theologically that there is evidence that infant baptism should be the normal practice in families where the gospel has taken hold, although there is no guarantee that children shall be believers. Bromiley (1996: 116).

He writes that many view believer’s baptism as the only legitimate New Testament form of baptism, although not necessarily immersion. Bromiley (1996: 114). Many tie in Christ’s call to baptize with the idea of making disciples, and nothing was said about infants. Bromiley (1996: 114). The question arises if infants are disciples, and I would think not, although they certainly can be disciples in waiting, again quoting one of my former lead Presbyterian pastors.

Bromiley notes that from Paul’s writings that tie belief and repentance with baptism it does not make sense to baptize infants that cannot hear the gospel or make a response of belief. Christ’s love for children is evident, but there is no direct Biblical command to include them in the baptism process, and there is no Biblical warrant to suppose that baptism should definitely precede belief and repentance. Bromiley (1996: 115).

Bromiley admits that the households in Acts may have included infants, but even if there were, there is no indication that they were baptized and states that it would be hazardous inference to use these verses to support infant baptism. Bromiley (1996: 115). He writes that the need for faith is correctly found in infant baptism, but that the personal confession found in Believer’s baptism is stronger. Bromiley (1996: 115). Reading Bromiley, it seems he reasons that it is good for infants within a Christian family to receive baptism, but that it would be even better for them to have believer’s baptism at a later date.

A Reasonable Position That Will Not Please Everyone

My reasoning is that believer's baptism appears the standard biblical theology. One believes and confesses as an adult, or at least a young person with adult responsibility granted and is baptized.

However, I cannot, because of lack of conclusive evidence, deny that entire households baptized in the New Testament, may have included infants.

Church Fathers, Irenaeus and Origen were reported to baptize infants. It is therefore at least theologically possible that the Apostles, with divine permission from Jesus Christ and the triune, God, allowed infant baptism. This may have been done while the Church accepted the standard biblical mandate for believer's baptism. The Baptist and Anabaptist can argue that the Church Fathers were in biblical error where infant baptism was practiced. The practices and theology of Church Fathers, not equal to documented inerrant, inspired, biblical doctrine of New Testament authors.

It is possible that more that one mode of baptism serves as a sign of being within the new covenant of Jesus Christ. Pastor Jon Courson has stated in his online sermons (paraphrased) that in the New Testament when there is theological conflicts with two different views, that they in a sense may both be correct.

From my academic theological perspective, this could be the case with the baptism issue. I am not dogmatic. This is not an attempt at wishy-washy theology, whatsoever. Anyone reading my work will realize I take dogmatic stances when there are greater cumulative evidence. Especially, with my PhD-MPhil studies. My work is a theological and philosophical attempt at balance.

For me, I therefore, was re-baptized years ago in a Mennonite Brethren church in what I believe is the stronger biblical model. But I have Presbyterian and mainline denomination friends that as adults are walking in the faith hoped for them in the new covenant through the infant baptism they received via parents. If these baptized children as adults stay within that tradition, I personally reason that this paedobaptism is sufficient as a sign of their personal obedient gospel walk. If they wished to join many Baptist or Mennonite churches, they would be required to take full immersion baptism.

As I pointed out in the discussion at the wedding reception, which was accepted; God chooses those in Christ (Ephesians 1, Romans 8), not based on infant baptism, or any baptism for that matter. Baptism is a sign of obedience in the gospel.

BROMILEY, G.W. (1996) ‘Baptism, Infant', in Walter A. Elwell (ed.), Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Books.
---

Saturday Part Two

The Dean Mennonite Birthday

Paraphrased:

Sophia his daughter, eight years old: Play hide and go seek with my friend and I!

Me: I am way too big and 'monstery' to hide. We will not fit under things!

Chuck: Yea, we are way too big!

Sophia's eight year old friend: (Pondering) Yea, I guess so, I did not think of that...

Me: But we can play Hide and go freak! Where we chase you!

Little girls: Yay!

Monday, February 05, 2018

Consenting disciples

Tour Radar.com: South of France

From the New American Standard 

Matthew 28:18-20

New American Standard Bible (NASB)

18 And Jesus came up and spoke to them, saying, “All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth. 19 [a]Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, 20 teaching them to observe all that I commanded you; and lo, I am with you [b]always, even to the end of the age.”

Baptism class

TriCity Church states (paraphrased) in the Baptism Class book cited below, that proposed baptized persons (for membership) are asked to discuss their testimony with elders and the church. (22).

In the past, I have been a member of a Presbyterian Church of America (Canada) and am in basic agreement with core doctrines and therefore could be a member. But, in regard to infant baptism, having taken membership class in the PCA years ago, I realize that those in leadership view infants and young children baptized as disciples.

I can grant this premise, in a sense and context, that infants and small children would be disciples in training, or possible future disciples, or like.

The book counters the claim of those that support infant baptism from Colossians 2: 11-12.

That being that Old Testament circumcision is replaced by New Testament baptism. (26). The book states that in contrast Colossians in mentioning that there is circumcision of the heart for those that are baptized in Christ. (26).

Colossians 2:11-12 New American Standard Bible (NASB)

11 and in Him you were also circumcised with a circumcision made without hands, in the removal of the body of the flesh by the circumcision of Christ; 12 having been buried with Him in baptism, in which you were also raised up with Him through faith in the working of God, who raised Him from the dead.

The book's interpretation of a circumcision without hands, as spiritual, is more reasonable and straightforward than a speculative theology of infant baptism, also known as paedobaptism, or pedobaptism.

At the recent TriCity Church, Baptism Class, which I was asked to assist with by the overseer, as I am a baptized Mennonite Brethren and of course a Christian theologian; I coined this idea that unlike those that practice infant baptism to bring children into the new covenant (Is this required in light of God's election of persons? Ephesians 1-2), our church is seeking:

Consenting disciples 

(I realize that some churches practice infant and believer's baptism.)

These are those that can discuss their testimony with the elders and the church.

This theology fits better with a believer's baptism view.

I have also received infant baptism within the United Church of Canada.

'Baptism Class' (2014), TriCity Church, Port Coquitlam.

Baptism November 2016

Monday, May 07, 2018

Luke 3: For church home group


I was asked to lead the next Home Group: Bible Study.

My response to questions...

Luke 3: 15-22

From Matthew Henry commentary

Thus the way of the Lord was prepared, and people were prepared to bid Christ welcome; for, when men's expectations are raised, that which they are in expectation of becomes doubly acceptable. Now when they observed what an excellent doctrine John Baptist preached, what a divine power went along with it, and what a tendency it had to reform the world...

The truth of John the Baptist's teaching of repentance, did connect with some Hebrew listeners that realized that the Hebrew religion was in need of reform. The people were politically under Rome and desired  political salvation, as in national independence. But more importantly a spiritual salvation was needed and therefore the need for the Messiah, Jesus Christ. John's preaching of a near Kingdom, implied that the Messiah was also near. Porter (1191).

The hearers that understood John's message significantly would realize that the Kingdom is expected and the King is also expected, via the message of John the Baptist.

John's baptism was a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. Porter (1191). Persons would be cleansed of sins, whereas the baptism associated with Jesus Christ was featured symbolically and spiritually as in cleansing and regeneration, in obedience; of course connected to the applied atoning and resurrection work of Jesus Christ.

I view baptism as largely symbolic, but can acknowledge, although it is not a human work of salvation (Ephesians 1-2), it is a human act of embracing that salvation. It is in that sense (at least), spiritual.

Titus 3

English Standard Version

4 But when the goodness and loving kindness of God our Savior appeared, 5 he saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, 6 whom he poured out on us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior, 7 so that being justified by his grace we might become heirs according to the hope of eternal life. 

1 Peter 3:21-22

English Standard Version (ESV)

21 Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ, 22 who has gone into heaven and is at the right hand of God, with angels, authorities, and powers having been subjected to him.

Jesus Christ participates in John's baptism as Jesus Christ was to obey God the Father in biblical religious practice as were all disciples in Jesus Christ.

The baptism of Jesus Christ places the believer symbolically under the applied atoning and resurrection work of Christ, the believer embracing salvific work through the act of obedience in baptism.

The unbeliever rejects this baptism and the associated salvific work and is post-mortem left with facing full judgement for sinful thoughts, acts and actions through a tainted, sinful nature.

The commandment to baptize disciples, as is Matthew 28, implies disciples should consciously embrace being a disciple in baptism, as opposed to disciples, instead, being disciples in waiting or hoped for disciples. The doctrine of believer's baptism is more reasonable, premise (s) wise than infant baptism, although there is some evidence for infant baptism as well (Acts 16, 1 Corinthians 1,  households baptized). I certainty would not call infant baptism, heresy.

Luke 3:21-22

English Standard Version (ESV)

21 Now when all the people were baptized, and when Jesus also had been baptized and was praying, the heavens were opened, 22 and the Holy Spirit descended on him in bodily form, like a dove; and a voice came from heaven, “You are my beloved Son.

[a] with you I am well pleased.”
[b] Footnotes: Luke 3:22 Or my Son, my (or the) Beloved Luke 3:22 Some manuscripts beloved Son; today I have begotten you

All the members of the Trinity are present in Luke 3: 21-22

HENRY, MATTHEW (1961), Editor, Leslie F. Church, Commentary on the Whole Bible: Genesis to Revelation, Grand Rapids, Zondervan.

PORTER, L.E. (1986) Luke, in F.F. Bruce (gen.ed.), The International Bible Commentary, Grand Rapids, Marshall Pickering/ Zondervan.

Wednesday, September 19, 2018

My brief PhD work in regard to Roman Catholic theology


Within my British PhD work, I found Roman Catholic Theologian, Alan Schreck quite useful academically, and have relied on Roman Catholic scholarship a fair amount in my academic work, on and offline, even with my somewhat different Reformed views.  I also documented work from  Roman Catholic theologian Peter Kreeft along with Ronald Tacelli.
---

Tradition

Roman Catholic theologian Alan Schreck states his Church agrees that the Bible is the inspired word of God,[1] but does not believe that the Bible is the only source of Revelation and spiritual guidance for Christians.[2]  A dividing point between Protestants and Catholics comes with Schreck’s idea that God within Catholic thought continues to select certain individuals that teach with God’s authority through the Holy Spirit.[3] Protestant and those within the Reformed camp have, at times throughout history disagreed, with the Biblical and theological interpretations of certain Roman Catholic leaders, in particular the Pope,[4] believed to be inspired by the Holy Spirit.[5]

Trinity

Alan Schreck demonstrates the Catholic view is quite similar to Reformed on this issue as he explains it is a central belief of his Church,[6] and that the early Church comprised the word Trinity from the Biblical idea for the one God consisting of three equal and distinct divine persons.[7]  

Baptismal Regeneration

Concerning the idea of baptismal regeneration, Schreck explains that Roman Catholics view infant baptism ‘as normally the first step in accepting God’s salvation.’[8]  He admits that the New Testament does not explicitly state whether or not infants or children were baptized,[9] but it is possible they were as ‘whole households’ are mentioned in the New Testament as receiving baptism.[10]  He reasons that there is no solid evidence that before the third century infants and children were baptized in the Church,[11] but by the fifth century this practice was universal in the Church.[12]  The theological hope with the practice of infant baptism is that the initial stages of regeneration have taken place through the faith of the parents,[13] as Schreck notes ‘Jesus does respond in this way when infants and children are baptized.’[14]  In the baptism process it is Christ that saves, and therefore salvation is not merited.[15] Whale reasons infant baptism demonstrates that Christ did something for a person, without waiting for human approval.[16] Rebaptism[17] would never be needed as although baptized Roman Catholics can turn from the faith, if they do turn back to Christ the initial baptism is sufficient.[18] The sacrament of infant baptism is one of the ‘foundational stones of Church.’[19]

Klein, Blomberg and Hubbard reason it is not Biblically clear what type of baptism should be practiced.
[20]  Infant baptism is not taught in Scripture directly,[21] and therefore it can be deduced the same could be stated for the associated concepts of baptismal regeneration with Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox Churches. However, legitimate theological inference leads to concepts of infant baptism,[22] and so there are also historical arguments for baptismal regeneration within the Christian community which includes Catholic,[23] Eastern Orthodox, and even in some cases Presbyterian, Lutheran and Episcopal. 

BROMILEY, G.W. (1996) ‘Baptism, Infant’, in Walter A. Elwell (ed.), Evangelical Dictionary of Theology, Grand Rapids, Baker Books. 

CALVIN, JOHN (1543)(1996) 
The Bondage and Liberation of the Will, Translated by G.I. Davies, Grand Rapids, Baker Book House. 

KLEIN, WILLIAM W., CRAIG, C. BLOMBERG, AND ROBERT L. HUBBARD, JR. (1993) 
Introduction to Biblical Interpretation, London, Word Publishing 

SCHRECK, ALAN (1984) Catholic and Christian, Ann Arbor, Michigan, Servant Books. WHALE, J.S. (1958) Christian Doctrine, Glasgow, Fontana Books.

[1] Schreck (1984: 41). 
[2] Schreck (1984: 42). Strictly speaking as noted, those in Reformed theology do trust in non-Biblical truths for spiritual guidance. Calvin admitted this in the context of Scripture and tradition.  Calvin (1543)(1996: 64).   I should also add that any reliance on philosophy and philosophy of religion is not strictly Biblical and I and many Reformed scholars look to philosophy for truth.  
[3] Schreck (1984: 42). 
[4] Calvin explains, within The Bondage and Liberation of the Will, his opinion that at that point in history the Papacy was beyond Reform.  Calvin (1543)(1996: 17).
[5] Schreck (1984: 42). 
[6] Schreck (1984: 14). 
[7] Schreck (1984: 14).
[8] Schreck (1984: 124). 
[9] Schreck (1984: 126). 
[10] Schreck (1984: 126).  
[11] Schreck (1984: 127).  G.W. Bromiley writes that Irenaeus (ca. 130-ca. 200) and Origen (ca. 185-ca. 254) were Church Fathers that could be traced back to the Apostles, and these men practiced infant baptism.  Bromiley (1999: 116).  If Irenaeus did practice infant baptism, this would trace the practice to the second century.
[12] Schreck (1984: 127). 
[13] Schreck (1984: 128). 
[14] Schreck (1984: 128). 
[15] Schreck (1984: 128). 
[16] Whale (1958: 158).
[17] Or Believer’s Baptism as it is known within Baptist and Anabaptist theology.
[18] Schreck (1984: 129). 
[19] Whale (1958: 158).  Whale does not view infant baptism as mere dedication or as a rite effecting regeneration and so his position is not identical to Schreck’s, although he does support the sacrament being practiced.
[20] Klein, Blomberg, and Hubbard (1993: 140).
[21] Klein, Blomberg, and Hubbard (1993: 140).
[22] Klein, Blomberg, and Hubbard (1993: 140).
[23] Schreck (1984: 124).  

God and Sovereignty

Peter Kreeft (1988) explains that the problem of evil is the most serious problem in the world,[1] and is a very serious objection to theism.[2] 

Roman Catholics Peter Kreeft and Ronald K. Tacelli (1994) suggest that God faces no real barriers in actions he wishes to commit, and that only what God allows, such as human sin, could thwart God’s plans.[3]   

They note if God did not allow human beings the option to misuse their freedom, they would not be human but animal or machine[4] having less value than creatures that had the potential to be persuaded by God to follow him, and turn from wrong doing.[5]

Satan

Kreeft, working with Ronald K. Tacelli, states Satan is a deceiver of humanity,[6] and this implies the assumption that Satan has personality.[7] 

In Regard to Calvinism

They note that some, but not all, forms of Calvinism subscribe to a view of hard determinism that denies any human free will.[8]  I would reason that in light of their statement[9] that most Calvinists are not hard determinists.[10]  

On Desires and Freewill

Kreeft and Tacelli approach desires in a similar way as Mele as they state that human beings have innate desire for natural things such as food and drink,[11] and external desires such as sports cars and political office.[12]  Kreeft and Tacelli’s innate desires concept would somewhat correspond to Mele’s intrinsic ones as these would be the inner most human desires.[13] Kreeft and Tacelli’s external desires would be similar to Mele’s extrinsic desires,[14] which would be secondary desires fulfilled in order to fulfill the deepest human desires.[15]

Immanence and Transcendence

Kreeft and Tacelli explain that God’s immanence means the creator must give created beings what they need.[16]  If God was not actively communicating being[17] to all his creation, his creation would cease to exist.[18] 

It is stated that God as transcendent is not part of the material universe.[19]  God is ‘other’ than his creation yet maintains it as transcendent.[20] 

Universalism

Kreeft and Tacelli explain that universalism is universal salvation and has been considered by some well-known orthodox Christians over the centuries[21] as a viable alternative to hell, although Kreeft and Tacelli reject this alternative.[22] 

KREEFT, PETER (1988) Fundamentals of the Faith, San Francisco, Ignatius Press. 

KREEFT, PETER AND RONALD K. TACELLI (1994) Handbook of Christian Apologetics, Downers Grove, Illinois, InterVarsity Press.

MELE, ALFRED R. (1996) ‘Extrinsic Desire’, in Robert Audi, (ed.), The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

[1] Kreeft (1988: 54-58).
[2] Kreeft (1988: 54-58).
[3] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 96).
[4] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 138).
[5] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 138).This assumes incompatibilism but it is true that human beings would be vastly different with significantly less freedom due to divine determining factors. 
[6] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 294).
[7] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 294).
[8] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 137).
[9] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 137).
[10] My research demonstrates that hard determinism is problematic for the majority of Calvinists and those within Reformed theology because Scripture (Romans 1-3, for example) condemns persons for sin and holds them morally accountable. Therefore, persons must at least freely embrace their own actions within soft determinism in order for punishment to be just.
[11] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 78).
[12] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 78).
[13] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 78). 
[14] Mele (1996: 259).
[15] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 78).
[16] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 93-94).
[17] Kreeft and Tacelli with the use of the word ‘being’ are stating that God, in an abstract sense, is communicating himself to his creation.
[18] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 93-94).
[19] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 93). 
[20] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 93). 
[21] This would, of course, provide another opportunity for a PhD thesis.
[22] Kreeft and Tacelli (1994: 286).

Edited from

Theodicy and Practical Theology (2010), The University of Wales, Trinity Saint David.