Monday, November 01, 2010

Practical Everyday Theodicy

Ohara Lake, BC (trekearth.com)

November 2, 2010 

I decided to email Wales early this morning. I have just received two confirmation emails that the Research Degrees Committee has signed off on my PhD and so it is official. They accepted the Examining Board's recommendation. I was emailed a copy of the official letter and will be sent a hard copy version. End 

October 25, 2010 

1. Apparently today there was a very standard research committee meeting to consider the two pass recommendations from my examiners for my Doctorate. So obviously I am expecting my final letter and degree in the post soon. Prayers appreciated. 

2. I reason that many of my linked bloggers have stopped blogging or slowed down in blogging. I am sympathetic to these bloggers and realize blogging can be quite tough, as in finding support, and as well time consuming. I am a little disappointed the comment numbers have dropped slightly, but thank you for some others that have stepped in. I support others where I can. As one can deduce I aim for honesty and transparency, although I do not believe in sharing my entire soul online and have not. My transparency, I suppose, offends some at times and I am also willing to fix, when I am allowed the opportunity.

However, controversy is the cost of doing this type of business. My page view numbers are now visible on the bottom right side of my blog. Site Meter has returned after being thrown into 'Blog Hell' by me for missing too many page views relative to Stats Counter which I loaded next on my computer. But, alas, Stat Counter misses some traffic as well, as when someone has just left a comment and there is no record of that blogger being on my blog! So, I brought Site Meter back and it is catching almost as many page views as Stat Counter. Blogger stats credits me with more traffic than both applications individually and I deduce is probably the most correct as it is domestic software made specifically by Blogger. It only provides the numbers. 

The Site Meter stats are a deduction of what I remember my stats being prior to deleting the program combined with the Stat Counter stats, so that is why the Site Meter stats are higher because they go back to when I started each blog. Satire and theology has received more traffic even though the blog is two years newer. The stats on this blog are for thekingpin68 only. If one 'cannot' or will not comment I still appreciate he or she visiting my blogs and boosting my page view numbers, even if just for a minute. It gives me encouragement and confidence that the Lord is leading me in this ministry and project which may parlay into future media ministry and business. 

Please realize, via Site Meter, Stat Counter, and Revolver Maps I can only know the general area of some visitors. Site Meter and Stat Counter can provide IP addresses but I have no definite idea whom they belong to and no way of finding out. I can only sometimes deduce that someone was on my blog with much certainty if he or she leaves a comment, and as stated someone left a comment the other day, before I reinstalled Site Meter, and Stat Counter did not catch the page view and never catches that commenter visiting. But anyway, as noted by visiting my blogs and generally increasing my page views you are supporting me even if you do not comment, link or follow me. And for that I thank you. 

3. A friend the other day challenged me on the practicality of my PhD thesis work. Well, that was a mistake as the thesis is 'Theodicy and Practical Theology'.;) Here are two examples of Practical Everyday Theodicy.

Example one, is when a person is suffering and a suggestion/solution is provided by another that things could be worse. Plantinga from my PhD: No matter how wonderful a world appears to be, no matter how many incredibly happy people there are, it is always possible there is an even better world containing more people who are even happier. Plantinga (1977)(2002: 34). Plantinga’s reasoning appears sound as any finite world God would create could always be better. Plantinga (1977)(2002: 34). Only an infinite world would be the best possible world, and it is debatable and unlikely God could create such a world. The fact that a world is created means it is not infinitely old or eternal, and so this would seemingly make the concept of a created infinite world untenable.

Things could always be better.

Things could always be worse.

The present realm is fallen (Genesis 3, Romans 1-3).

The fact things could be worse does not necessarily mean things are good enough that one is not significantly suffering under the problem of evil.

Example two, is the often rather evangelical way of trying to deal with suffering as in putting the local church and universal Church in the place of something else.

So, trying to replace a potential wife or husband with church/Church related activities, even if a person does not have contentment from the burn of 1 Corinthians 7.

Significant suffering may still occur.

As well, trying to replace the needs of an elderly widow, widower, divorcee or someone that is virtually single because he or she has a very ill elderly mate, with church care.

The local church and universal Church may meet some of these needs but as they are corporate bodies and not the missing individual, some needs cannot be met and therefore significant suffering may still occur unless there is God given contentment with being a single elderly person.

PLANTINGA, A.C. (1977) God, Freedom, and Evil, Grand Rapids, Wm. B. Eerdmans, Publishing Company.

Some more recent photos I found via trekearth.com

Gering, Nebraska Maxwell, Nebraska Igazu, France Alfonso XII Monument, Madrid, Spain Accident waiting...

33 comments:

  1. lol that's quite the picture...I'm not sure if that's geniously innovative, perhaps a contraption made out of necessity, or ridiculously foolish!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice to meet you today via Facebook and Blogger.

    I think that man is going to have a rather difficult time negotiating turns with that bike cart.

    Cheers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Russ,
    There is always something on your blog to keep my mind busy in the middle of the night. Tonight I will be wrestling with the idea that God wills evil. I don't think I can agree with that statement. Allows it, maybe, but WILLS it? Hmmmmmm. Cheers! Jen

    ReplyDelete
  4. What you wrote on theodicy was interesting, I find it a difficult and fascinating topic.
    I suppose created worlds can't be infinitely old... if there was no beginning then time could never reach the present.
    I've also found suffering to be relative. I could always tell an upset friend that they aren't starving to death in a third world country or something along those lines and that their problems are trivial, but reality is just so different to us in the West and it's not. If that made any sense to anyone!

    ReplyDelete
  5. 'Russ,
    There is always something on your blog to keep my mind busy in the middle of the night. Tonight I will be wrestling with the idea that God wills evil. I don't think I can agree with that statement. Allows it, maybe, but WILLS it? Hmmmmmm. Cheers! Jen'

    Jen, I do not want to be held responsible for a school teacher's insomnia!;);>

    Well, if God is infinite and omnipotent and omniscient what he allows he also wills.

    The key is motive. God's motives are pure as is his nature.

    As well, even if God was technically not infinite, omnipotent and omniscient, I reason he could deduce all things to the point where he could still prevent evil, if he so desired.

    The attributes would still be virtual. So what he allowed he would will.

    The key would still be motive.

    Thanks.:)

    ReplyDelete
  6. 'What you wrote on theodicy was interesting, I find it a difficult and fascinating topic.'

    Cheers, Bri.

    'I suppose created worlds can't be infinitely old... if there was no beginning then time could never reach the present.'

    Yes.

    'I've also found suffering to be relative. I could always tell an upset friend that they aren't starving to death in a third world country or something along those lines and that their problems are trivial, but reality is just so different to us in the West and it's not. If that made any sense to anyone!

    I suppose suffering can also be somewhat related to expectations as well, admittedly. Your point is good.

    In general I reason if a human need, an actual need is not met, and there is not contentment without, or perhaps ignorance, there will likely be suffering.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you Russ for sharing this..I am now sharing with a few others.. i believe your blog is quite thought provoking..keep it up :)

    http://bongoisme.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks, Bongo, I appreciate your support and it was good to meet you online recently via Facebook and Blogger.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you Russ. I added your blog to mine.. Hopefully we can connect and bring readers together :) It was great connecting you on Facebook too :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. "Accident waiting"... hahahaha
    the last picture is funny!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I agree, Aline.

    He may think himself a big shot inventor, but he is perhaps a fool.

    Trying turning...

    Cheers.:)

    ReplyDelete
  12. I tell myself that it doesn't matter how many comments I get on my blog. Avoiding looking at the statistics is a key part of it. But no matter how hard I try, there is still a part of me that wants attention. Thankfully I haven't felt a need to question God over this!

    May the Lord grant you your diploma quickly.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks, Looney, you make a good point.

    I do want to build successful blogs and perhaps tie them into more media in the future.

    But, God's will be done.

    ReplyDelete
  14. A lot of people sadly seem to have a knee-jerk reaction to theology and categories of theology like theodicy as being irrelevant to practical everyday life, and therefore effectively useless.
    But theology and philosophy guide one's whole pattern of thinking. People often get stuck in a rut of belief or specific thinking habits, that they refuse to see things in new ways. And the culture of mass media does not help. The great thing that inspires me with hope, is the possiblity of internet, blogs and social media to at least bring critical thinkers together, expose false ideas, and encourage more discussion and debate about issues.

    ReplyDelete
  15. 'A lot of people sadly seem to have a knee-jerk reaction to theology and categories of theology like theodicy as being irrelevant to practical everyday life, and therefore effectively useless.'

    Agreed, quite Western.

    'But theology and philosophy guide one's whole pattern of thinking.'

    Yes, and problematic that many avoid deeply challenging themselves on why they hold certain views.

    Like I said awhile ago, late last evening, too much comfort in life is often the enemy of questioning worldview.

    'People often get stuck in a rut of belief or specific thinking habits, that they refuse to see things in new ways.'

    Yes.

    'And the culture of mass media does not help. The great thing that inspires me with hope, is the possiblity of internet, blogs and social media to at least bring critical thinkers together, expose false ideas, and encourage more discussion and debate about issues.'

    Yes, so please read my blogs.

    My name and thekingpin68 blog cited on #1 blog-Huffington Post.com (according to Technorati).

    Huffington

    ReplyDelete
  16. I handed out an estimated 230 Gospel Tract/Candy Packs tonight. May God's Word not return void, and may some fruit come of that, so that souls might be saved as a result. To many Christians, Halloween is an evil night, but to me, it's the easiest time of the year to hand out gospel tracts to people, because they come right to your door.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Well-done and may your tracts do much good.

    Jeff, if you dressed as me tonight I will be truly hurt!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Russ,

    Keep in mind some of us follow you on RSS which is not included on you site meter.

    Timothy

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks much, Timothy, good point.

    I appreciate you reading it that way as well.

    ReplyDelete
  20. <')((><

    <")((><

    Thank you, Cloudia.

    There is a somewhat 'fishy' discussion going on over at my other blog...

    Islam and Christianity

    ReplyDelete
  21. hey, kingpin68>..:) thanks for leaving a comment on my blog, i would love to have reciprocal blog followers could you find me some?:) thanks!!~_~

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thanks, Shy,

    Say, if you will follow me on my Google/Blogger application on my thekingpin68 blog I will follow you back on your blog.

    Russ:)

    ReplyDelete
  23. All of these boards doing this and that, what a long haul to earn an education.... but c'est la vie, congrats!
    -Dr. Delighted-

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hey,im her again..~_~
    just followed you already... hope you'll follow back..

    ReplyDelete
  25. Great waterfall picture in France, I wonder how that waterfall compares to Canada's Niagara Falls?
    -Curious George-

    ReplyDelete
  26. 'Anonymous said...
    All of these boards doing this and that, what a long haul to earn an education.... but c'est la vie, congrats!
    -Dr. Delighted-'

    Yes, I am 'board' with it.

    Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  27. 'Great waterfall picture in France, I wonder how that waterfall compares to Canada's Niagara Falls?
    -Curious George-'

    Well, I have been to Niagara.

    Cheers.

    ReplyDelete
  28. 'Hey,im her again..~_~
    just followed you already... hope you'll follow back..'

    Following back, thanks.;)

    ReplyDelete
  29. hello Russ,

    You have some beautiful pix posted. I'll try to start visiting more. Congratulations Dr. :)

    ReplyDelete
  30. oh,by the way Dr. Russ ,i have an award for you for posting lovely blogs!

    visit my site to claim it!
    http://sevencupsofrice.blogspot.com/2010/11/another-blogger-award-from-eat-pray.html



    loves♥

    ReplyDelete