Saturday, June 22, 2013

Jonathan Edwards (PhD Edit)

New Zealand-Dean Hintz
Myanmar-Facebook

The first photo is from the Green Dragon where The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit films have been made.

Jonathan Edwards And Libertarian Free Will: August 2006

Older work above on the same subject, some of which ended up in the PhD.

Sovereignty and Providence

Jonathan Edwards (1703-1758)(1729)(2006) writes that God has the power to bestow upon anyone of his creatures good, evil, or indifference for the greater good.[1]  This sovereign control is accepted despite the obvious problem of evil occurring in God’s creation.[2]  Attempts to harmonize strong concepts of God’s divine control over his creation, with the apparent corrupt nature of what he has made in regard to the problem of evil, will be described within this thesis as sovereignty theodicy.[3]  In Law of Nature, Edwards  (1731-1733)(2006) explains that providence is the means by which God governs the world as the supreme judge of the universe.[4]  Reichenbach notes that providence is how God guides and cares for his creation.[5]  He further reasons that God on one hand possesses wisdom in order to direct his creation within his plans, and on the other hand has the power by which he attempts to implement his plans.[6]  Reichenbach deduces that God’s providential plans allow for significant human freedom and choices to occur.[7]

Free Will And Determinism

Edwards thinks there is a major difficulty within libertarian concepts concerning free will.[8]  If the human will determines the will and resulting choices, since every choice must have a cause, then a chain is established where a will and choice is determined by a preceding will and choice. Therefore, if the will determines its own free acts, then every free act of will and choice is determined by a preceding act of will and choice. If a preceding act of will also be of free choice, then that too was self-determined.[9]  What Edwards is stating is that in the act of causing a free choice (choice1), the cause of that choice was also made freely (choice2), and the cause of that choice was made freely (choice3) and so on. 

This theological concept of Edwards would tie into the philosophical concept of vicious regress[10] since with a regress it could not be determined what caused a human choice initially, because every free choice was caused by a previous free choice. Edwards instead reasoned that human choices were a result of human nature originally created by and within God’s will. God therefore wills all things, and is the primary cause of all actions.[11]  I reason human actions, and any angelic or demonic actions would be accepted  as a secondary cause[12] in order to avoid concepts of hard determinism, where only God or the first cause would be morally responsible for acts.[13] 

Blackburn counters that some form of metaphysical libertarianism[14] postulates that free choice is not causally determined, but is also not random.[15]  It is suggested that an agency situated outside of human nature,[16] in regard to making human choice, is possible but likely ‘fantasy.’[17]  It appears human choice should be traced back to human nature.[18] 

Edwards writes that God controls all things.[19]  The sovereignty approach can present the remedy for the problem of evil in a practical sense, not just primarily philosophically.[20]  The approach needs to focus on the idea that the triune God consummates his Kingdom and gives things meaning.  It seems rather meaningless for a Christian to readily accept a notion of God willing all things for a greater good within a theological system when the greater good is not vividly practically explained within the system, at least in general ultimate terms.[21]

BLACKBURN, SIMON (1996)  Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy,  Oxford, Oxford University Press.

EDWARDS, JONATHAN (1729)(2006) Sovereignty of God, New Haven, Connecticut, Jonathan Edwards Center, Yale University.
http://edwards.yale.edu/archive/documents/page?document_id=10817&search_id=&source_type=edited&pagenumber=1

EDWARDS, JONATHAN (1731-1733)(2006) Law of Nature, New Haven, Connecticut, Jonathan Edwards Center, Yale University.

EDWARDS, JONATHAN (1754)(2006) Freedom of the Will, Flower Mound, Texas. Jonathanedwards.com.

FEINBERG, JOHN.S. (1994) The Many Faces of Evil, Grand Rapids,  Zondervan Publishing House.

FEINBERG, JOHN.S. (2001) No One Like Him, John S. Feinberg (gen.ed.), Wheaton, Illinois, Crossway Books.

POJMAN, LOUIS P. (1996) Philosophy: The Quest for Truth, New York, Wadsworth Publishing Company.

REICHENBACH, BRUCE (1986) Predestination and Free Will, Downers Grove, Illinois, InterVarsity Press.

STACE, W.T. (1952)(1976) Religion and the Modern Mind, in John R. Burr and Milton Goldinger (eds.), Philosophy and Contemporary Issues, London, Collier Macmillan Publishers. 


[1] Edwards (1729)(2006: 414).
[2] Edwards (1729)(2006: 414).
[3] Feinberg (1994: 124-143).
[4] Edwards (1731-1733)(2006: 553).
[5] Reichenbach (1986: 115).
[6] Reichenbach (1986: 115).
[7] Reichenbach (1986: 118).
[8] Which would correspond to modern concepts of libertarian free will and incompatibilism.
[9] Edwards (1754)(2006 2.1: 1-1-2). 
[10] Blackburn (1996: 324).
[11] Edwards (1754)(2006 2.1: 1-1-2). 
[12] Pojman (1996: 596).  Stace (1952)(1976: 29). 
[13] Pojman and Stace both state a secondary cause must freely commit acts in order to be significantly morally accountable.  Pojman (1996: 596).  Stace (1952)(1976: 29). 
[14] Blackburn (1996: 218).
[15] Blackburn (1996: 218).
[16] It appears Blackburn is discussing a human agency.
[17] Blackburn (1996: 218).
[18] Edwards (1754)(2006 2.1: 1-1-2).  Blackburn (1996: 218).  Within my Reformed world view I reason God created this nature and simultaneously influences and wills all human choice.
[19] Edwards (1729)(2006: 414).
[20] This is where empirical theology can be beneficial.
[21] I can admit this can be a weakness within sometimes overly philosophical Reformed approaches.

34 comments:

  1. Go to System=> Cache Management and enable the caching features.
    Another way you can update your site is to regularly check and improve upon your website's SEO status. While they may not deliver the same wow factor as Flash, HTML sites load much faster and require less memory to operate.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Another way he could update his site would be to obtain actual human comments and Facebook and Google+ 'Likes'.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I loved it but only used it for rice for the longest time. The first thing you want to do is prepare the sushi rice, since it has the greatest preparation time.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like Japanese food but not as much as Chinese or Thai.

    Not interested in Sushi. Personally I would feed it to Rebel and Muffin if they were still alive...

    ReplyDelete
  5. I paid it for you


    Hey,

    Alright, I'm not blind and I can see
    that you are struggling a little bit
    online... Everyone is asking money
    from you before actually giving you
    the methods to make that money...

    Well, that sucks. And that's why
    I want to give you a little something.

    I have paid for this, so you could get
    an access.

    Access here

    Now, I want to say that it's totally
    cool, and I don't ask anything in
    return, this is just a little something
    from me.

    It didn't cost me an arm and a leg,
    so don't worry about it, just make
    sure you grab it ;)

    Grab it here

    Why I'm doing this? Well, back in the
    days when I was a struggling marketer,
    someone gave me a hand when I most
    needed it, so I am giving it back o n you :)

    Enjoy,
    Sara Baker

    ReplyDelete
  6. Suρeгb blog by thе way! mу web site - vision without glasses does it work

    ReplyDelete
  7. Please dο keep uр the fantaѕtic ωork. Lοoκ at mу blog - earth4energy

    ReplyDelete
  8. Eхcellent blog yοu have here but
    Ι ωas curious abοut if yοu knew of any discussiοn boards that covеr
    thе same topіcs discussеd herе?
    I'd really love to be a part of online community where I can get feed-back from other knowledgeable people that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Many thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  9. One can check out Facebook for discussions.

    I have made a very conscious determined decision NOT to blog on Facebook or Google+ other than with my headers and brief discussions if challenged or asked for help.

    If a debate occurs as one did with a critic from Australia in 2012, I think it was, I debated and answered and then kindly let him know that I was willing to do more on my blogs but no more on Facebook.

    If I blog on Facebook and Google+ I am basically setting up further blogs and although I would be giving myself more immediate readers I would also be setting myself up for too much time online.

    ‘Get a life’. This is the expression that always comes to mind.

    As a good friend told me at church today after we finished counting the offering, yes I am that trusted, Facebook and Blogger are not real life in a sense. This is why I try to connect in reality with persons that show interest because I think reality is where the Lord wants us to deal.

    Back to the main point, I do not want to simply duplicate DR. RNM and S&T on Facebook and to a lesser extent the much less popular Google+ by more theological/philosophical blogging, but I do want to use social media to be social as a potential connection for reality.

    I just do not see spending endless hours with 3-4 blogs online dealing in reality.

    Obviously, even with what I do with a lot less human comments than I used to have it takes up many hours a week. But my traffic with blogs combined has gone from approximately 10, 000-15, 000 pageviews a month to 20, 000 to 34, 000 pageviews a month over the Spring. I am not sure why, but perhaps because of my continued increase in fortunately quality posts, by God’s grace, and many spam pageviewers combined with some human loyalists.

    It is interesting to see both my blogs ranked with one of the highest rated theological blogs in the world with Technorati, which I will not name. I am not stating it is better than mine, or that I am better, it is different and with more current events not surprisingly, but surely with all the Facebook ‘Likes', it must receive many times more readers than I receive and yet somehow my two blog’s rankings are similar to that site.

    Not sure how my blogs are making it...

    ReplyDelete
  10. In addition to making sure that your rice is perfectly cooked, pasta should be cooked properly as well, stopping just short of completely done. Weird smiley faces, "bite me," and other 50's inspired designs. 84 with free shipping at this time of writing on Amazon. Here is my site - noi com dien on

    ReplyDelete
  11. 'Weird smiley faces, "bite me," and other 50's inspired designs'

    In the pasta? What are you five years old?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi there to all, how is the whole thing, I think every one is getting more from this web site, and your views are pleasant for new viewers.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Stop working!


    Hey,

    Start making crazy profits
    without investing to much
    of your time and money!

    Check it right here

    It's all done-for-you method,
    so you just need to step in
    and start boosting your income
    every single day!

    Your private access is below

    I am sure this will be helpful
    if you are still trying to earn
    money online!

    Enjoy,
    Sara Baker


    ReplyDelete
  14. Hey,

    You are a WINNER...

    You've been chosen for a special
    VIP training.

    Read More Details Here...

    Follow the instructions on the next
    page to get access.

    Confirm YES or NO on this page.

    This exclusive training will be taken down soon!

    Talk Soon,

    Paul

    ReplyDelete
  15. The regular toaster heats up fast and
    uses less power than the regular oven.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Excellent happy analytical attention to get detail and can foresee difficulties just before these people take place.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I have been trying to reach you in
    Canada. I needed to show you
    this amazing new way to make money...

    http://www.iprofitcommission.com/click.html?x=a62e&lc=Ch&mc=j&s=xbE9&y=u&

    Enjoy,

    Charles

    ReplyDelete
  18. Balance due: $0.00
    Why?: Gift from CEO
    Reference # C5004
    Customer I.D
    Download location:
    http://clicks.aweber.com/y/ct/?=G5tcU&m=3dIi_VaW6_FoaIO&b=lZ2SI_2jTJ3KjW_2tNu6w


    Thank you
    Customer Notifications

    ReplyDelete
  19. PennyStockProphet - LUVE - 13 Cent Momentum Alert: Walmart A Current Client!

    ReplyDelete
  20. 'Anonymous said...
    I have been trying to reach you in
    Canada. I needed to show you
    this amazing new way to make money...'

    Sure, Chuck...

    ReplyDelete
  21. 'Anonymous said...
    PennyStockProphet - LUVE - 13 Cent Momentum Alert: Walmart A Current Client!'

    Oh yes, I am sold, with the Prophet and 'Luve' lingo...just like questionable forms of Christianity.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets
    I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
    I've been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this. Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

    ReplyDelete
  23. More people think "should be a young child" but when you are more old, you feel that reality is hard but it's yours. And might be the unique thing you have. I like be old, although it hasn't the same colors as when you were small.
    I'd love to be doing those photos *.*
    Thanks for your visit DR! ^^

    ReplyDelete
  24. I prefer to be an adult as well Sarah, but the way I workout and think I am youthful.

    Please have a good week.

    Thank you once again for the very kind words about the photos. I just commented back at yours again.

    ReplyDelete